The Nathan Fyfe Thread

Started by Slammer, April 14, 2012, 07:26:25 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

who to come in for fyfe? (please no hate, i know there are many fyfe polls but please vote)

n.reiwoldt
17 (12.5%)
Sidebottom
28 (20.6%)
Cloke
7 (5.1%)
Chapman
4 (2.9%)
Blair
3 (2.2%)
Cyril
1 (0.7%)
Pav
5 (3.7%)
Whitecross
13 (9.6%)
Cornes
4 (2.9%)
Tippett
11 (8.1%)
selwood (would require ledger-->treloar)
10 (7.4%)
ward (would require ledger-->treloar)
0 (0%)
hayes (would require ledger-->treloar)
3 (2.2%)
barlow (would require ledger-->treloar)
8 (5.9%)
masten (would require ledger-->treloar)
3 (2.2%)
Montagna (would require ledger-->treloar)
0 (0%)
Ziebell (would require ledger-->treloar)
7 (5.1%)
carazzo (would require moving smedts forward)
6 (4.4%)
birchall (would require moving smedts forward)
2 (1.5%)
bock (would require moving smedts forward)
4 (2.9%)

Total Members Voted: 8

Bigjim

Yeah the Martin trade was a Monday morning knee jerker. Love the way he plays so will probs keep him all year regardless what he scores. Another optioned I've toyed with us fyfe to ebert, bouman to carazzo. Have had 300k sitting in the bank since I made the last last minute cox to Kruezer trade just before round 1 lockout.

Pros
IMO ebert will be a consistent 100 point per game player, class midfielder in an improving side. Carrots sures up my Shakey looking backline, shouldn't have to touch it for a while baring injury/ suspension

Cons
Burn through two trades. Burn through two trades

Hmmm gotta love Monday morning brainsnaps ha. All this pending on fyfes shoulder scans of course

hannebery2rohan

well as long as you manage the trades carefully, burning them early isn't really a problem. i do, but it just means i don't have the luxury of trading someone out who pings a hammy or gets suspended for a couple of weeks. and 115,000 teams are going to have to burn a trade regardless on fyfe. i've got martin and am keeping him as well, i think he'll come good. at least i hopeso.

newfreofan

I'm trading fyfe to sidebum in sc and robbo in dt. Too many options have more 'what ifs' attached to them than I'd like

bomberboy0618

He is definitely out for a while so you should trade Fyfe.

Hot_Dogs


ben_020285

Who are your other forwards? I'd need to know before I can place a vote.

twinkle

Quote from: reesbr on April 16, 2012, 11:09:12 AM
Luke Dahlhaus as a unique?

He is a little jet - but can't see him averaging full premo scores. Maybe 85-95 tho

Seriously thinking about going Fyfe -> Treolar and pocketing the $400K ready for a mid upgrade in a couple of rounds once some rookies are fattened up.


Jake8

Which player should i get for Fyfey?

mudgee

With Ball out for the year, you would have to go with Sidebottom out of those guys. No love for K-Tip?

Jake8

Do u think Tippett will score consistently?

hannebery2rohan

adelaide have sydney, geelong, carlton then collingwood between rounds 6 and 9. i think tippett might find it a bit tough over that period.

ben_020285

G'day Jake. Who are your other forwards mate?

Luigi197

Yeah might want to see the rest of your fwd line; and possibly look around if you have a M/F dpp link in your team.

But i voted Sidebottom out of those options as he is nice and consistent. He is averaging 94 so far, and he hasn't shown his best at all. Watch him improve.

Jake8

My other forwards are Franklin,Goodes,Martin,Porplyzia,Smith,Milera,Kennedy and Hall.

ben_020285

Quote from: Jake8 on April 16, 2012, 04:08:06 PM
My other forwards are Franklin,Goodes,Martin,Porplyzia,Smith,Milera,Kennedy and Hall.

You have just the one player from the round 12 byes so go with Sidebottom. He is looking good too and he will be getting more time in the midfield with Ball gone for the season.