Problem.

Started by Tyes, April 12, 2012, 08:06:37 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which trade should I stay with?

Grimes => Waters
5 (45.5%)
Golby => Hargrave
5 (45.5%)
Stay with both and keep Dickson.
1 (9.1%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Tyes

Now that Dickson isnt playing i'm provided with a problem.
I currently have traded out Grimes to Waters and Golby to Hargrave. But now that Dickson is out should I reverse one of these trades and swap in Milera? And if so which one? :)

Zombie2.5

I voted Golby to Hargravy but i thought that was the one not to do.

I meant Keep Golby, trade Grimes to Waters and then trade dickson to kennedy/milera.

Personally i dont think milera can keep this up but you probably already have kennedy so milera is next best.

Windigo

Grimes>Waters is okay.

Keep Golby, will make you cash and people are being over critical.

Merret is back and admittedly, I was a little nervous that maybe Golby could be dropped for Drummound. But it's not the case, he looks safe for JS and surely you wait one more week on him. I cannot believe people want to oust him so quickly. 

Andrew

Just Dickson -> Kennedy or Milera, if you really need to sell him? Grimes is only going to improve particularly v Richmond this weekend. Golby I don't know alot about but only has a breakeven of 60 apparently so could easily give him another week.

Tyes

The only reason i'm considering getting rid of Golby is I see this as the only week you could sideways for Hargrave, and I dont want to miss the boat on him. So yeah I guess that's the one I was leaning to reverse. Thanks guys :) Also any other good forward rooks other than Milera? I have Kennedy already.

Windigo

Didn't Golby score two more than Hargrave last week?  ???

I'd still keep him around.

I don't think there are any decent FWD rookies?  ???

Andrew

Nope. Have you got a MID/FOR in your midfield? Move him into the forward line and pick up a mid rookie instead like Greene :)

lollipop man

Quote from: Windigo on April 12, 2012, 08:19:06 PM
Didn't Golby score two more than Hargrave last week?  ???

I'd still keep him around.

I don't think there are any decent FWD rookies?  ???
What?? Hargrave more than doubled Golby's score last week.

Scrads

Another option could be Treloar if he is named.

Windigo

Quote from: lollipop man on April 12, 2012, 08:23:10 PM
Quote from: Windigo on April 12, 2012, 08:19:06 PM
Didn't Golby score two more than Hargrave last week?  ???

I'd still keep him around.

I don't think there are any decent FWD rookies?  ???
What?? Hargrave more than doubled Golby's score last week.

I mean week one.  ;)

Tyes

Quote from: Scrads on April 12, 2012, 08:24:05 PM
Another option could be Treloar if he is named.

Yeah I saw that he was named in the GWS squad, not to keen on trading for him considering it's a Sunday squad with an extended bench and such. Only other viable option is Cameron I think, has good JS but he will get some low scores too.

Tom_16

Keep grimes as he will come good. Trade out dickson to whoever you are planning and go golby to hargrave.