The Official Greg Broughton Tread

[Smileys Bruisres]

hi guys,

i have the useless Broughton also i am looking at trading him for Hargrave and make some cash. ( i allready have Lake )

also looking at trading Dickson or Hall or even both for Milera & Kennedy as i know there price is going to climb.

Problem is only 2 trades any advice would be appreiciated.

What should i do?

[Barra17]

I have broughton, I didn't have enough cash to go carrazzo, already had goddard and scotland. I'm thinking mumford to ryder and broughton to carrazzo.

[Ajax22]

hi guys,

i have the useless Broughton also i am looking at trading him for Hargrave and make some cash. ( i allready have Lake )

also looking at trading Dickson or Hall or even both for Milera & Kennedy as i know there price is going to climb.

Problem is only 2 trades any advice would be appreiciated.

What should i do?

I also have all of Broughton, Dickson and Hall although I do have Kennedy already

Keep one of Dickson or Hall. Trade the other off to Kennedy. I'm not entirely sold on Milera's scoring ability or JS yet. Remember he's only played Port and GWS and at some point I'm pretty sure the Saints will have to fit Schneider in. Kennedy looks to be a gun rookie this year with good JS and will be well worth ousting one of Dickson/Hall for. Wait for teams but at this stage I would lose Dickson

Broughton I'm keeping. It's only been two games and its not really he hasn't scored the best in either of them. He was always gonna end up playing a role on Stevie J against Geelong and a long trip to play Sydney doesn't really provide the best scoring opportunities, just look at some of the other Freo players that were down in that game (ie Fyfe, Pav)

[Andrew]

If you don't have Marty Clarke but have Broughton like myself, isn't the no brainer trade to made Broughton -> Marty Clarke? Even if Broughton recovers his scoring, this trade would make me over $250k. I'd have to play Clarke and one of Bugg/Ellis/Morris if I do the downgrade, I'm comfortable with that..?

[rider]

This hasn't really helped  me  :-\ it seams that half reckon keep/wait and half reckon flip (upgrade/downgrade).

[rider]

If you don't have Marty Clarke but have Broughton like myself, isn't the no brainer trade to made Broughton -> Marty Clarke? Even if Broughton recovers his scoring, this trade would make me over $250k. I'd have to play Clarke and one of Bugg/Ellis/Morris if I do the downgrade, I'm comfortable with that..?

considering this myself.

[Andrew]

If you don't have Marty Clarke but have Broughton like myself, isn't the no brainer trade to made Broughton -> Marty Clarke? Even if Broughton recovers his scoring, this trade would make me over $250k. I'd have to play Clarke and one of Bugg/Ellis/Morris if I do the downgrade, I'm comfortable with that..?

considering this myself.

I didn't mention that Clarke is set to rise at least $150k if he keeps up his current scoring rate. But I'm planning to keep him as D7/8 all season as I think he'll be consistent. A big challenge v Carlton this Friday night, but you feel that he's only going to get better as the season goes on, so quite a safe trade from how I see it.

Good luck.

[Smileys Bruisres]

hi guys,

i have the useless Broughton also i am looking at trading him for Hargrave and make some cash. ( i allready have Lake )

also looking at trading Dickson or Hall or even both for Milera & Kennedy as i know there price is going to climb.

Problem is only 2 trades any advice would be appreiciated.

What should i do?

I also have all of Broughton, Dickson and Hall although I do have Kennedy already

Keep one of Dickson or Hall. Trade the other off to Kennedy. I'm not entirely sold on Milera's scoring ability or JS yet. Remember he's only played Port and GWS and at some point I'm pretty sure the Saints will have to fit Schneider in. Kennedy looks to be a gun rookie this year with good JS and will be well worth ousting one of Dickson/Hall for. Wait for teams but at this stage I would lose Dickson

Broughton I'm keeping. It's only been two games and its not really he hasn't scored the best in either of them. He was always gonna end up playing a role on Stevie J against Geelong and a long trip to play Sydney doesn't really provide the best scoring opportunities, just look at some of the other Freo players that were down in that game (ie Fyfe, Pav)

Thanks for the advice will wait for teams and make final decision.
Below is my team at the moment maybe i should get rid of someone else....?
I scored 2173 with this side in round 2
Also i am abit worried about having to many GWS players this week as they play the Eagles can't see to many high scores from them thats why i was looking at Milera. 43,700 left in the bank

STK
1. GODDARD, Brendon [MID] 474,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: WBD
2. SCOTLAND, Heath [MID] 493,500 +0 (+0)     NEXT: COL
3. BURGOYNE, Shaun [MID] 354,700 +0 (+0)     NEXT: ADE
4. BUGG, Tomas 104,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: WCE
5. CLARKE, Marty 141,500 +0 (+0)     NEXT: CAR
6. BROUGHTON, Greg 416,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: BRL
7. LAKE, Brian 255,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: STK
RESERVES
. MORRIS, Steven 104,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: MEL
9. ELLIS, Brandon 116,700 +0 (+0)     NEXT: MEL EMERGENCIES
MIDFIELDERS
10. ABLETT, Gary 554,700 +0 (+0)     NEXT: ESS
11. BOYD, Matthew 573,800 +0 (+0)     NEXT: STK CAPTAIN
12. DELEDIO, Brett [DEF] 452,100 +0 (+0)     NEXT: MEL
13. SWAN, Dane 598,300 +0 (+0)     NEXT: CAR
14. MAGNER, James 85,800 +0 (+0)     NEXT: RIC
15. DANGERFIELD, Patrick [FWD] 349,800 +0 (+0)     NEXT: HAW
RESERVES
16. SHIEL, Dylan 104,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: WCE
17. WINGARD, Chad 157,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: SYD EMERGENCIES
RUCKS
18. COX, Dean 532,000 +0 (+0)     NEXT: GWS
19. GILES, Jonathan 117,800 +0 (+0)     NEXT: WCE
RESERVES
20. REDDEN, Jarrad 104,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: SYD
21. STEPHENSON, Orren 98,700 +0 (+0)     NEXT: NTH
FORWARDS
22. FYFE, Nathan [MID] 486,600 +0 (+0)     NEXT: BRL
23. FRANKLIN, Lance 503,000 +0 (+0)     NEXT: ADE
24. GOODES, Adam [MID] 491,000 +0 (+0)     NEXT: PTA VICE CAPTAIN
25. MARTIN, Dustin [MID] 442,500 +0 (+0)     NEXT: MEL
26. PORPLYZIA, Jason 202,500 +0 (+0)     NEXT: HAW
27. SMITH, Devon [MID] 121,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: WCE
28. HALL, Aaron 98,700 +0 (+0)     NEXT: ESS
RESERVES
29. CAMERON, Jeremy 104,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: WCE
30. DICKSON, Tory 98,700 +0 (+0)     NEXT: STK EMERGENCIES

[Doyle]

Keep? I am, I think, hopefully he'll come good. Hopefully ::) and how can you make a thread 'official' ?

[Ajax22]

hi guys,

i have the useless Broughton also i am looking at trading him for Hargrave and make some cash. ( i allready have Lake )

also looking at trading Dickson or Hall or even both for Milera & Kennedy as i know there price is going to climb.

Problem is only 2 trades any advice would be appreiciated.

What should i do?

I also have all of Broughton, Dickson and Hall although I do have Kennedy already

Keep one of Dickson or Hall. Trade the other off to Kennedy. I'm not entirely sold on Milera's scoring ability or JS yet. Remember he's only played Port and GWS and at some point I'm pretty sure the Saints will have to fit Schneider in. Kennedy looks to be a gun rookie this year with good JS and will be well worth ousting one of Dickson/Hall for. Wait for teams but at this stage I would lose Dickson

Broughton I'm keeping. It's only been two games and its not really he hasn't scored the best in either of them. He was always gonna end up playing a role on Stevie J against Geelong and a long trip to play Sydney doesn't really provide the best scoring opportunities, just look at some of the other Freo players that were down in that game (ie Fyfe, Pav)

Thanks for the advice will wait for teams and make final decision.
Below is my team at the moment maybe i should get rid of someone else....?
I scored 2173 with this side in round 2
Also i am abit worried about having to many GWS players this week as they play the Eagles can't see to many high scores from them thats why i was looking at Milera. 43,700 left in the bank

STK
1. GODDARD, Brendon [MID] 474,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: WBD
2. SCOTLAND, Heath [MID] 493,500 +0 (+0)     NEXT: COL
3. BURGOYNE, Shaun [MID] 354,700 +0 (+0)     NEXT: ADE
4. BUGG, Tomas 104,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: WCE
5. CLARKE, Marty 141,500 +0 (+0)     NEXT: CAR
6. BROUGHTON, Greg 416,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: BRL
7. LAKE, Brian 255,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: STK
RESERVES
. MORRIS, Steven 104,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: MEL
9. ELLIS, Brandon 116,700 +0 (+0)     NEXT: MEL EMERGENCIES
MIDFIELDERS
10. ABLETT, Gary 554,700 +0 (+0)     NEXT: ESS
11. BOYD, Matthew 573,800 +0 (+0)     NEXT: STK CAPTAIN
12. DELEDIO, Brett [DEF] 452,100 +0 (+0)     NEXT: MEL
13. SWAN, Dane 598,300 +0 (+0)     NEXT: CAR
14. MAGNER, James 85,800 +0 (+0)     NEXT: RIC
15. DANGERFIELD, Patrick [FWD] 349,800 +0 (+0)     NEXT: HAW
RESERVES
16. SHIEL, Dylan 104,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: WCE
17. WINGARD, Chad 157,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: SYD EMERGENCIES
RUCKS
18. COX, Dean 532,000 +0 (+0)     NEXT: GWS
19. GILES, Jonathan 117,800 +0 (+0)     NEXT: WCE
RESERVES
20. REDDEN, Jarrad 104,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: SYD
21. STEPHENSON, Orren 98,700 +0 (+0)     NEXT: NTH
FORWARDS
22. FYFE, Nathan [MID] 486,600 +0 (+0)     NEXT: BRL
23. FRANKLIN, Lance 503,000 +0 (+0)     NEXT: ADE
24. GOODES, Adam [MID] 491,000 +0 (+0)     NEXT: PTA VICE CAPTAIN
25. MARTIN, Dustin [MID] 442,500 +0 (+0)     NEXT: MEL
26. PORPLYZIA, Jason 202,500 +0 (+0)     NEXT: HAW
27. SMITH, Devon [MID] 121,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: WCE
28. HALL, Aaron 98,700 +0 (+0)     NEXT: ESS
RESERVES
29. CAMERON, Jeremy 104,200 +0 (+0)     NEXT: WCE
30. DICKSON, Tory 98,700 +0 (+0)     NEXT: STK EMERGENCIES

1 round doesn't really mean much. In the overall time you hold either Milera or Kennedy I think Kennedy will easily outscore Milera and make more money. Schneiders due back in 2-3 weeks or so and could put pressure on Milera's spot (along with Saad and others I've neglected). Trades are vital throughout the year, theres no use trading out a benchie if they're both playing and looking like they will make money which both Hall and Dickson will do if they continue to get a game. In your circumstance it looks worthwhile to scrap one of them but I wouldn't get rid of both. Whilst it is nice to have players from a range of teams Kennedy still scored well last week in a side that got smashed last week and should continue to be a solid on-field rookie

Last year Broughton scored 139 against Brisbane at home so you really have to at least give him this week to see if he can go big again. Saying that though he did only pull a 79 when he played away against Brisbane last year so we better just hope the home ground advantage helps out.