The Official Greg Broughton Tread

Started by LeBron4MVP, April 10, 2012, 01:49:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

So Big Decision this week, whats your stance?

Downgrade (Waters, Dempsey, Other)
11 (22.4%)
Upgrade (Birchall, Carrazzo, Scotland)
9 (18.4%)
Swap (Heppell, Hanley, Bock, Fisher)
4 (8.2%)
Keep (Going to score better!)
18 (36.7%)
Hold (Waiting to trade)
7 (14.3%)

Total Members Voted: 5

LeBron4MVP

Everyone is thinking, lets just share some ideas about this issue, seems to be the most apparent atm, thoughts?

Scrads

Good thread, even though I have Broughton, I am getting sick of all the Broughton threads on the main page :P

sledgey7

ahhh. so the other 84 threads were unofficial

Windigo


sledgey7


Plastic Boy

Keeping, tired of talking about it to be honest

Slashers

Gone, and don't care what he does, won't be coming back.

Football Factory

I would keep ... he's like Shaw (melbourne's weather) crappy one day perfect the next .. They will both probably score 120 next week

Slashers

Well I want Queenslands weather. Beautiful one day... Perfect the next...!

Windigo

Broughton has the scoring ability.

No one has answered my question about how he managed to score 90 a game in 2010. I'm willing to bet he wasn't playing midfield!

Wasn't he playing the loose man in defense? I'm hoping he turns it around this week for me.  ::)

MGK1

Not sure what to do with Broughts, but I'll give him another week.

Football Factory

Quote from: Slashers on April 10, 2012, 02:18:15 PM
Well I want Queenslands weather. Beautiful one day... Perfect the next...!
lol   ;D

Holz

Quote from: Windigo on April 10, 2012, 02:20:27 PM
Broughton has the scoring ability.

No one has answered my question about how he managed to score 90 a game in 2010. I'm willing to bet he wasn't playing midfield!

Wasn't he playing the loose man in defense? I'm hoping he turns it around this week for me.  ::)

is he even playing the loose man in defense, I agree with you in that he doesnt have to play in the midfield to score, but correct me if im wrong but he isnt even playing a DT friendly position in the backline.

For me he is my only underperfoming back and if couch is not named this week than i will need to trade him out as going for overall i need cash for upgrades early and cant have a guy doing nothing on my bench. Eski looks real good this season and is priced over 100k less, a trade is worth 100k so it comes down do i think eski will outscore broughton, at this stage I do. Going Couch to Greene if couch is not playing is a good move as it looks like greene will make 100k more than couch.

Alot of people are just doing straight swaps, but i think i can make around 200k on the double trade so thats why im looking at it.

sya87

what is the go with duffield? will his injury affect brought's scoring?

sledgey7

Quote from: Windigo on April 10, 2012, 02:20:27 PM
Broughton has the scoring ability.

No one has answered my question about how he managed to score 90 a game in 2010. I'm willing to bet he wasn't playing midfield!

Wasn't he playing the loose man in defense? I'm hoping he turns it around this week for me.  ::)

he was playing in defense. sometimes accountable and sometimes loose. lot's of tackles and getting used to run it out a lot.