Coniglio to Greene Trade _ discussing pros and cons

[david17]

im thinkin bout gettin rid of hampton to greene i dont no if i should waste a trade dis early tho but if greene gonna make me cash quicker mite pay off any thoughts

[Chopps]

I was going to trade in Greene but now I'm thinking otherwise.

Coniglio will be a great player, he has started slow but I feel in another game or so he'll be firing.

He is also handy to have as a 7th midfielder all year given that he has great JS, and he might be handy to call upon should a midfielder get injured/suspended or rested.

It's gonna be hard to keep a rookie for the season with the byes. He will have go rd11 unless you like donuts!

he is already playing as my 7th Mid, why couldnt i keep him for byes the offload him rd 14

[Flame]

The poll is fairly clear on the argument!

[Chopps]

it is clear, surely others have better players to trade though or is the money factor?

I haven't seen apart from my original post any persuasive arguments apart from yea its a good idea but why?

my original post wasnt meant to convince me to consider it that much

[Windigo]

I would have thought this was pretty good.

Ousting Greene in the long run will cost you two trades.

getting him in, and getting him out. Yes, he will make you some "quick cash," but the same as Coniglio he will have to be culled.

Seriously, can Greene keep this up? In round one he was everywhere sure, but had little impact, IMO, Coniglio was more impressive. I'd like more from Cogs for sure, but slow and steady win the race.....I hope.  :-\

60 from a rookie who can improve and can tear games open is enough incentive for me to keep him.  ;)

But people read what they want to hear.

[Plastic Boy]

If people are saying trade for no good reason you've got opinions from people that make knee jerk reactions.

Coniglio isn't scoring 20.., he's in the 50/60 range, and both games he's spent time on the pine banged up. Had he not spend time on the bench with his shoulder he could have scored 15-20 that quarter and he would have ended up with 80 and we wouldn't be having this discussion.

Keep him

[Windigo]

If people are saying trade for no good reason you've got opinions from people that make knee jerk reactions.

Coniglio isn't scoring 20.., he's in the 50/60 range, and both games he's spent time on the pine banged up. Had he not spend time on the bench with his shoulder he could have scored 15-20 that quarter and he would have ended up with 80 and we wouldn't be having this discussion.

Keep him

The plastic man is talking sense.  ;)

[Justin Bieber]

Actually considering it. Depends on Mummy and co.

I need Marty Clarke in and if I do this trade I will make heaps of dough.

Mind due GWS vs West Coast

[Master Q]

If people are saying trade for no good reason you've got opinions from people that make knee jerk reactions.

Coniglio isn't scoring 20.., he's in the 50/60 range, and both games he's spent time on the pine banged up. Had he not spend time on the bench with his shoulder he could have scored 15-20 that quarter and he would have ended up with 80 and we wouldn't be having this discussion.

Keep him

The plastic man is talking sense.  ;)

I agree. There's a reason everyone had him pre-season  ;)

[PowerBug]

Those price prediction are assuming that both players score their projected score. So if Greene only get 70 and Coniglio picks up 80 then it'll be worth less than 60k. :)

That's why i won't be doing the trade.

[mike_3456]

In isolation I'm not entirely happy about doing this trade but I really need to do it to go Broughton->Goddard.

[Football Factory]

I have the same problem ... wont be trading out Con .. patience is a virtue