HELP!

[kevin07]

Gday lads,

Couple of issues with my squad:

1. I have, like most people, the Broughton issue, do I keep or flick?

2. Missed out on Toby Greene, should I get him in for Coniglio?

3. What to do with Parker?

4. Giles is currently my 3rd ruck, should I downgrade McIntosh for the cash and make him my second? (I know McIntosh got a ton this week, but it was against GWS)

5. I have to play one of Ellis, Morris or Smedts, and they all suck. So what should I do there?

Thanks in advance

[nathan11]

1) flick up or down doesnt matter
2) no
3) keep
4) No
5) fix  at same time as 1

[deekay]

1) flick up or down doesnt matter

so you would flick?

[ThePendles]

1. You can hold on too him and risk the price drop hoping that he'll eventually rise back up or you can trade him for Waters (if you don't already have him). Waters is about 100k cheaper so will free up some cash, and his price will definetly increase this week (WCE have GWS next week).

2. If I had a choice I'd hold on to Conigilio, you would of had to pay the extra money for a reason so don't jump off just yet. That being said, Greene is definitely one you don't want to miss out on and I'd try squeeze him into the team somehow. If you have a m/f player like Hall you can trade him for Greene. If you don't have a m/f player or anyone else you want to trade out, by all means trade Coniglio.

3.  Hold on too him.

4. Should of went with the 1/3 ruck combo from the start... if you think you can use the money to upgrade somebody else by all means do it, but I'm sure your priorities will be with Broughton and Congilio.

5. Hold on to them, Morris scored 70+ this week against Collingwood. They're not many other rookie back options plus Ellis has a lot of upside, start him. Everybody else is in the same boat so don't worry.

[Milney]

1. Keep him,will improve.

2. Keep him. Will only get better.

3. Trade him to Greene.  Parker will be a sub suspect going fwd, also not much of a price rise with latest scores.  Make cash from trade down to Greene.  In 2-3 weeks they will be the same price and you will have $250k increase in your bank/side in that time.

4. No. McIntosh only going to improve.  Giles can then just make cash for you.  If you need the $$$ desperately then maybe.  If you do number 3, then you will have spare $$.

5. Just pick one and hope they get 60-80.  Which one should each week.

[kevin07]

Ok so I think, respite getting mixed reviews, that I will go Parker to Greene. This leaves me with $142,800, which I can then use to upgrade Broughton to the likes of Scotland, or downgrade to Waters, freeing up more cash for a potential upgrade later. Thoughts?

[ThePendles]

Ok so I think, respite getting mixed reviews, that I will go Parker to Greene. This leaves me with $142,800, which I can then use to upgrade Broughton to the likes of Scotland, or downgrade to Waters, freeing up more cash for a potential upgrade later. Thoughts?

Get Waters, great value for his price and will defintely go up in price. The extra money would just make it a whole lot easier for you to upgrade.

[kevin07]

Cheers

[PowerBug]

1) Hold. :-\
2) No trade, not worth what could only be a 30k gain. It could be 100k but it could be 30k
3) Keep
4) No
5) play Morris this week.

[nathan11]

1) flick up or down doesnt matter

so you would flick?

I have yes but will have a look at draw and teams to decide if he stays out

[Windigo]

Keep Coniglio.

You will burn two trades just like that.

[kevin07]

Yeah, I'll keep Coniglio, but more concerned about Broughton and how to get in Toby Greene.

As it stands, I've gone Broughton to Waters and Parker to Greene.

Thoughts?