Going to cop a bit here - would like to be convinced otherwise!

[elephants]

S. Coniglio ---> T. Greene

and

A. Hall/T. Dickson ---> A. Kennedy

I know, mental.

The way I see it though is despite being two trades (maybe less) behind the leaders I will now have the best scoring rookies going forward.

Let's be honest. Rookies are only there to be upgraded to premiums. It is for this reason I am looking to get the rookies with the smallest breakevens in an attempt to make my team full of premiums quicker. I don't want to be spending 15 weeks waiting for the expensive Coniglio to top out at 300k when I can have Greene (who on the back of two tons) could be at a similar point in a third of the time!

I dunno, I am keen. Anyone have a strong case otherwise?

And please, no sarcasm.

Cheers!

[Artax]

Thinking of dropping Cogs also, for Greene! Don't knwo what to do with Dickson and Hall...already have Kennedy!

[PowerBug]

will coniglio make you money?? Yes
Will Hall and Dickson make you money?? Yes

" "  Kennedy  " "?? Yes
" "  Greene  " "?? Yes

Which two will make thew most money?? Kennedy and Grenne.
Is it worth two trades?? I think so.

[elephants]

Yeah cheers man. Really looking for a reply from those strongly opposed to early trading...

Sold on the second move - not sure who to trade out of Dicko or Hall though :-\

[elephants]

will coniglio make you money?? Yes
Will Hall and Dickson make you money?? Yes

" "  Kennedy  " "?? Yes
" "  Greene  " "?? Yes

Which two will make thew most money?? Kennedy and Grenne.
Is it worth two trades?? I think so.

Thanks mate, pretty much my line of thinking...

[Windigo]

Wish I kept Greene in the first place, but I'm not chasing after him.

It goes against what I'd do.

Just do it, go with what you think is best.

[Football Factory]

Both trades probably a good idea ... I like the Kennedy trade more than the conigs trade

[owenbond007]

not sure what cogs scored today? Ill prob only go one - dickson for kennedy/greene.

[elephants]

Wish I kept Greene in the first place, but I'm not chasing after him.

It goes against what I'd do.

Just do it, go with what you think is best.

Yeah, I am going to factor in my personal thoughts before I get others advice a lot more now...

Both trades probably a good idea ... I like the Kennedy trade more than the conigs trade

Same but I see the value increase difference between Conigs and Greene as being pretty huge!

[MGK1]

as soon as you drop coniglio he will probably get 100 :p

[elephants]

not sure what cogs scored today? Ill prob only go one - dickson for kennedy/greene.

Coniglio scored 53 last week and 60 this week...

Dickson is a fwd and Greene is a mid??

[thatguy]

Having seen gws live down here today, this move doesn't appear to be that bad. Coniglio really didn't have much impact v Roos, while Greene was often used as link out man from back 50m. His disposal was terrible and he turned it over far too often, but he seems to have a better understanding of where to run at this stage to both get the ball and into space.

[elephants]

as soon as you drop coniglio he will probably get 100 :p

Probably, but I am a good bloke like that!! I'll do it for thise with the persistence to keep him :P

[owenbond007]

oh thought greene was a dual position player. That f$%ks my seady state of mind plans

[Football Factory]

Wish I kept Greene in the first place, but I'm not chasing after him.

It goes against what I'd do.

Just do it, go with what you think is best.

Yeah, I am going to factor in my personal thoughts before I get others advice a lot more now...

Both trades probably a good idea ... I like the Kennedy trade more than the conigs trade

Same but I see the value increase difference between Conigs and Greene as being pretty huge!

Depends what you think a trade is worth .... Conigs-Greene = 40k + how much he will go up compared to coniglio .. will conigs continue his bad run and will Greene continue his good run im gonna say 80k ? difference .. 40k + 80k = 120k ... is that worth the trade ?