An idiot who gambled on Clancee Pearce, trade or not?

Started by Johnnysd, April 07, 2012, 11:51:25 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Clancee Pearce for?

K Tippett
0 (0%)
C Cornes
4 (25%)
Someone else under 360k
2 (12.5%)
Sit one more week
10 (62.5%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Johnnysd

He dogged it rd1 after killing it preseason. Now should I trade him or not? Possible trades could be:

K Tippet
C Cornes

What do y'all think?

nathan11


Colliwobblers

definately wait a week will make your choices a lot clearer

2 large cokes

you've got him now mosewell wait another week but i wouldn't be looking at either of those guys. tippet will only ever score good when Adelaide win. and even when they do he won't score hundreds most of the time. and cornes. well his just cornes. not fantasy relevant. last week will probably be his only good score of the year.

Adamant

I would wait a week and if he pulls out another score under 70, trade him to CALLINAN or mabye Porps pending this weeks results.
:P

Slashers

#5
Its no secret (because I posted it in a few threads), prior to round 1 I thought he was a huge smokie... come half time I KNEW that wasn't to be the case... by the end of the game I had already started looking for a replacement. He's a spud and he can't handle the pressure!! >:(
DT Talks Roy (special agent Sub-Marine) has even picked him as the sub this week!!
A few had tried to talk me out of it (I should have listened). A few suggested to me were Fasolo and Motlop. Motlop is an interesting one (Round 1 80DT, 87SC) as he's named in the middle this week. Fasolo should have a better year than his ok round 1 scores (69DT, 74SC). My initial toss-up was between Pearce or Hill (WCE). Hill (56DT, 70SC) obviously had a better round 1 than Pearce but it seems eventually I might have been disappointed with pick him too.
I've never, ever been interested in Cornes (either one, don't care), and I've never had Tippett.
ATM though I'm considering Luke Dahlhaus! WOW! Didn't know much about him, but after doing some research he could be a real star. I like him!!
I haven't traded yet, but I WILL be prior to final lock-out (waiting last minute due to the temporary lack of the reverse feature).

dmagnus

Why anyone would pick Clancy escapes me... You should take him this week, he'll be vested.

Belongs in the WAFL

elephants


Slashers

3QRT time and CLANCEE.... Why couldn't you do this in round 1?? !! FFS?
Still didn't want you because you had 16 in you, but did you have to back it up with a possible 80+!!

Noz

Scored 91 keep him another week should have a reachable break even

elephants

He is pretty hit and miss. Lyon loves him though and will give him every chance which is great!

Johnnysd

Would have prefered it that he dogged it again rather than do this. Bloody DT. I will be the death of me one day...