backline - who to pick

[browny_wce]

ok guys im not sure who to pick as i think Buggy will back it up again this week
my backline is:
Birch, Delids, Waters, Scotland (105), Hargrave, Clarkey, Broughts
(Buggy, Ellis)

give us your thoughts lads

[picker_man]

put broughton on the bench for bugg lol :P 
nah who you have starting on the field atm i think will be the best scorers this week

[esquire]

If you were going to bring Bugg in it would have to be for Hargrave, however that's a lot of value to have sitting on the bench. I wonder how Hargrave will go with Howard out and up against Tex, Tippett and their mates like Callinan, Porlyzia and Petrenko? He could still go alright (as he did against WCE with a similar forward structure), but if your main question "Who should Bugg replace?" I'd choose Hargrave for the pine.

[picker_man]

If you were going to bring Bugg in it would have to be for Hargrave, however that's a lot of value to have sitting on the bench. I wonder how Hargrave will go with Howard out and up against Tex, Tippett and their mates like Callinan, Porlyzia and Petrenko? He could still go alright (as he did against WCE with a similar forward structure), but if your main question "Who should Bugg replace?" I'd choose Hargrave for the pine.

i think hargrave would be a safer pick to keep on the field over clarke if you were going to do anything

[Football Factory]

ok guys im not sure who to pick as i think Buggy will back it up again this week
my backline is:
Birch, Delids, Waters, Scotland (105), Hargrave, Clarkey, Broughts
(Buggy, Ellis)

give us your thoughts lads

As you have it imo

[esquire]

i think hargrave would be a safer pick to keep on the field over clarke if you were going to do anything

I was at first thinking Clarke, but after watching the way Hargrave gathered possessions last week and Adelaide's forward pressure, and Clarke playing against Richmond, I ended up opting for Hargrave out. Pragmatically, I would leave Bugg on the bench purely as he is the cheapest rookie, chosen as a cash cow whereas the extra $ for the others were paid for a reason.

[owenbond007]

bugg over clarke for me

[Mozza3]

I'd keep it as it is, maybe Bugg for Clarke if you really want to play Bugg.

[youl_R_FCK]

Up to you but bugg will out score Clake

[browny_wce]

id like to see Broughton go off but the price i paid for him, he's a starter

im confident Hargrave will score well

its really Bugg or Clarke  ???

[Windigo]

Hm, don't let last weeks score cloud your judegement.

Clarke is in great side, while Bugg is an emerging team. I'd go the safe option in Marty.

[yorgis]

as is  +1

[elephants]

Bugg vs Clarke.

I say Clarke only just!

[nathan11]

id like to see Broughton go off but the price i paid for him, he's a starter

im confident Hargrave will score well

its really Bugg or Clarke  ???

Have faith in broughton he is named in the mids just hope he gets to play there most of the game

[esquire]

Hope you left Hargrave on the field. 2 mins into quarter 2 and right up there.... Don't listen to me....  :D