Rookie Mids

[Ricochet]

I don't think Shiel will get the vest this week. They have others coming back who have not played any footy.

My thoughts exactly, and he has now played a ressies games, half an AFL game and another ressies game. So he should be right to go.

[Master Q]

I'm leaning towards Smith. Both have a chance of getting vested but Smith seems like he can score well hence he's starting on for me with Shiel as Emergency.

[Madsnake]

These are my thoughts:
Clay smith will score 70-80 and get the red vest.
Shiel, if vested will score 50 odd but will most likely play half a game on ball and then get put up fwd when he's stuffed, if he can get a few goals/marks up there and avoid the vest he'll get 80-90.

[kilbluff1985]

clay smith will score 20 points atleast more

[Madsnake]

clay smith will score 20 points atleast more

Depending on whether he gets the vest or not..