Rookie Mids

Started by Madsnake, April 06, 2012, 02:40:06 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which of these two will score higher and avoid the Vests?

Clay Smith
9 (47.4%)
Dylan Shiel
10 (52.6%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Madsnake

I'm stressing that one of these will cop the vest.

Tory Dickson and Luke Parker are named on the extended bench along with Smith so there is probably a good chance that 2 of those three will be the vested ones.

As for GWS vests, Shiel is named on ball but when has that ever made a difference.

picker_man

i have a feeling both will to, exspecially when smith's body shut down on him last week they know he will be a star and might treat him like one
so id go shiels on field but its a tough one

Madsnake

I'm leaning towards Shiel aswell..

Football Factory

Tough question .. gut feeling is Smith will get the red vest

Madsnake

Quote from: FOOTBALL FACTORY on April 06, 2012, 02:46:16 PM
Tough question .. gut feeling is Smith will get the red vest

Being named on the ball really makes sense that he would.. They probably both will, just a question of who will score more in the time that they're on the field then doesn't it?

Football Factory

Yeah current form says Smith will score better .. from 1 game .. lol

crabapples

#6
I sill reckon smith will cop a dump on his chest.. I mean wear the red vest, especially with griffen playing, also smith would make a great impact sub against a young dynamic adelaide

Football Factory

If you want to know if its a green or red vest then wait till they name them ... then its an easy choice

Kuruki

I don't think Shiel will get the vest this week. They have others coming back who have not played any footy.

yorgis

maybe griff will cop the vest close to 3/4 time ?? i think dickson will tho' especially if jones does'nt play well.

crabapples

Dickson will get subbed if jones isnt playing well??

nickyt


crabapples

Quote from: yorgis on April 06, 2012, 03:24:14 PM
maybe griff will cop the vest close to 3/4 time ?? i think dickson will tho' especially if jones does'nt play well.
[/b]

Madsnake

Quote from: FOOTBALL FACTORY on April 06, 2012, 03:03:15 PM
If you want to know if its a green or red vest then wait till they name them ... then its an easy choice

We won't know the vests for either of these teams before lockout bro..

Football Factory