Shiel vs. Smith

[nickyt]

Have both in the midfield as rookies, one however must be benched. I also have coniglio and magner who I am set on starting above both of these two, who do you guys think will score higher and why?

[picker_man]

smith on field ;D

[esquire]

smith on field ;D

I agree. Shiel will be a gun and in the coming weeks will be start worthy, but not sure if this is the week. A couple more run arounds and he'll be starting for me.

[nickyt]

Yeh, i can see what you mean, just a little nervous as Smith is starting fwd pocket, and inevitably GWS will get smashed (against roos) ;D Almost feel more comfortable starting shiel though, and that is what the poll is indicating...

[Football Factory]

Shiel i think ..

[Haddy1.0]

League teams on foxtel has smith named last on the bench. Could get the vest so Shiel for me.

[nickyt]

League teams on foxtel has smith named last on the bench. Could get the vest so Shiel for me.

Are you sure this is Devon Smith, I thought he was named FP...

[Torpedo10]

League teams on foxtel has smith named last on the bench. Could get the vest so Shiel for me.

Are you sure this is Devon Smith, I thought he was named FP...

He was, i think Haddy means Clay Smith who was named on the bench.

[nickyt]

League teams on foxtel has smith named last on the bench. Could get the vest so Shiel for me.

Are you sure this is Devon Smith, I thought he was named FP...

He was, i think Haddy means Clay Smith who was named on the bench.

Thought so, would have made my decision very easy if he was named last on the bench though!

[Haddy1.0]

Sorry guys I did man clay smith. So in that case I'd probably field Devon smith. I have both Devon in my forwards and Shiel in the mids only because clay was named last on the bench.