Brian Lake - Should I keep or trade

Started by KRZTRK, April 05, 2012, 10:59:53 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

KRZTRK

I took a risk on lake at the start of the season & after 1 game and seeing what he had to show, not liking what I saw. I've got about 120k in the bank & my defenders are as follows

Goddard,Deledio, Golby, Lake, Hargrave, Ellis, Morris, Bug, Wilkes

With lake costing 250K I have $370K to trade with but can't really see anyone that's standing out. Was thinking either of the GWS guys costing $105K that scored 71 & 74 & just upgrading them when their price goes up but thought I would ask everyones opinion.

For those interested the rest of my team is as follows
Swan, Boyd, ablest, Mitchell, Selwood, Shiel, McDonald, Magner
Cox, Kruezer, Giles, Stephenson
Frankin, Fyfe, Mrtin, N Riewoldt, Pfiefer, Kennedy, Hampton, Dickson, Couch

Scored 2100 for the first round so really with 2 or 3 upgrades will be pushing 2250s

Windigo

I'd keep for another week. Golby at 3 in the defense is dodgy.

Ricochet

Very weak backline mate with only two premiums??

Beau Waters is within the 370k

KRZTRK

i knew i would get some critiscm (however u spell it) about my backline which is y i included the rest of my team so you would know where all the money went & how it was possible to score 2100 with a backline like that.

reddragon

i've got the same dilema but i think stick with him for 1 more week and then trade if he spuds it up again. In saying that i dont really rate his chances of scoring big against the crow's foward line.

possible chioses:

marty clark
beau waters
nick malceski
chris yarran

Colliwobblers

+1 reddragon all great choices but if you can field a full backline this round do the trade next round as the right choice will be twice as clear for you

Holz

go waters or eski, it would make your backline somewhat respectable, but wait till next week just to make sure.

Master Q

Keep him for one more week. More point in trading this week than next.

Bak2Form

my backline is "weak" too because i have players like golby and hargrave but atm they are scoring higher than broughton,shaw etc.. so my backline is keeping up with premiums which is helping me field a better team elsewhere. i upgrade my defence last due to backmen seem to be very up and down. Enright looks like a good straight swap for golby or hargrave in a few rounds

Holz

Quote from: Bak2Form on April 05, 2012, 02:54:44 PM
my backline is "weak" too because i have players like golby and hargrave but atm they are scoring higher than broughton,shaw etc.. so my backline is keeping up with premiums which is helping me field a better team elsewhere. i upgrade my defence last due to backmen seem to be very up and down. Enright looks like a good straight swap for golby or hargrave in a few rounds

Hargreaves is a good pick, it really depdns which premiums your talking about guys like Lids, goddard,birchall, waters, malceski  are pulling good numbers.

Bak2Form

Quote from: Holzman on April 05, 2012, 03:09:30 PM
Quote from: Bak2Form on April 05, 2012, 02:54:44 PM
my backline is "weak" too because i have players like golby and hargrave but atm they are scoring higher than broughton,shaw etc.. so my backline is keeping up with premiums which is helping me field a better team elsewhere. i upgrade my defence last due to backmen seem to be very up and down. Enright looks like a good straight swap for golby or hargrave in a few rounds

Hargreaves is a good pick, it really depdns which premiums your talking about guys like Lids, goddard,birchall, waters, malceski  are pulling good numbers.

i only got god,birch and lids as my premium backs. and i got waters in dt pro