Stupid trade?

[essendon2]

not for my team as I didn't start with Goodes - for a mate:

Goodes to Callinan
D.Smith to C.Ward
trying to prove to him that it's a stupid trade

[The Grundles]

Very very very very stupid trade.  Why would you think about trading an absolute champion of the game and a huge cash cow for 2 average players in round 2 of all rounds?

Please play it cool and give it some time mate and you will see both goodsey and devon will come good  8)

[Binga]

Dumbest thing I've ever seen. Whilst I think D Smith to Ward looks good in 5-7 weeks.  Why would you trade out Goodesy? He didn't exactly fail last weekend, he will average 95+ by the end of the year Callinan will be lucky to push 80.

[Chopps]

it has stupid all over it.

trading out a premium that will only get better second half of the season and be serviceable 90+ first half is just insane

[essendon2]

don't boo me!
it's for a mate!!
I'm 281st you can check haha I don't have Goodes

[picker_man]

are you seriouse? you had a ripper week which gives you the luxury of not having to make any trades this week let alone this abysmal one

[FlipFlops]

are you seriouse? you had a ripper week which gives you the luxury of not having to make any trades this week let alone this abysmal one

LOL it's for his mate, not him  ::)

[essendon2]

are you seriouse? you had a ripper week which gives you the luxury of not having to make any trades this week let alone this abysmal one

LOL it's for his mate, not him  ::)

THANK YOU

[picker_man]

are you seriouse? you had a ripper week which gives you the luxury of not having to make any trades this week let alone this abysmal one

LOL it's for his mate, not him  ::)

THANK YOU

fair enough, trades like these come up with my m8's... only when there stoned but ::) prolly says it all

[essendon2]

are you seriouse? you had a ripper week which gives you the luxury of not having to make any trades this week let alone this abysmal one

LOL it's for his mate, not him  ::)

THANK YOU

fair enough, trades like these come up with my m8's... only when there stoned but ::) prolly says it all

ahhaha 15's too young  ;)

[Tom_16]

Whoever voted no or give it one more week should be banned from this site.

[essendon2]

Callan Ward may average more than Goodes this year

[Colliwobblers]

many of us "think" goodes will finish the season much stronger than he starts it (hes has 3 years in a row) STILL he will average 85+ as an absolute minimum for the first half of the season, so you wouldn't trade him out just to trade him back in again because he WILL average 100+ in the back half - he always does (maybe 98 i think one year for the 2nd half).

as for the other parts of the trades well no to that too.

Kennedy magner and bugg may average more than goodes this year too, the odds tho? i think goodes is a lot safer than ward or rooks or most other players in the fwds.

[picker_man]

many of us "think" goodes will finish the season much stronger than he starts it (hes has 3 years in a row) STILL he will average 85+ as an absolute minimum for the first half of the season, so you wouldn't trade him out just to trade him back in again because he WILL average 100+ in the back half - he always does (maybe 98 i think one year for the 2nd half).

as for the other parts of the trades well no to that too.

Kennedy magner and bugg may average more than goodes this year too, the odds tho? i think goodes is a lot safer than ward or rooks or most other players in the fwds.

+1 agaon colli

Callan Ward may average more than Goodes this year

he may but its realy not the point goodes is fwd, ward is mid so would rather a 95 ave from goodes in the fwds then a 100 ave from ward in the mids ::)

[elephants]

Ward (100) + Callinan (75)

VS

Goodes (95) + D. Smith (70-80)

On points maybe option 1 leads (according to my speculation for what it's worth). But definetely not worth throwing away 2 trades ::) :P