The "Who to field"thread: Round 2

[stew42]

Need one of Mudbrick, Magnet or Shiel in my mids
Debating between Bugg and Ellis in my backs
And one of Couch, Dickson and Hall in mah fwds...

[Ajax22]

Magnet and Bugg for sure

Probably Couch if named on the field otherwise safe option is Hall

[mezzoculo]

Nice topic - why not make it a weekly poll? Throw up a dozen options (three per line?), add names that you may have missed,  give people the option to change their votes and close the poll one hour prior to lockout on the first game of the round.

Would be a great resource for us all!

[elephants]

1 of Bugg or Ellis or Morris

2 of Magner, Coniglio and Shiel

1 of Giles or Redden

2 of D. Smith, Hall, Smedts and Dickson

[JBs-Hawks]

1 of Bugg or Ellis or Morris

2 of Magner, Coniglio and Shiel

1 of Giles or Redden

2 of D. Smith, Hall, Smedts and Dickson

Bugg

Magner and Coniglio

Wait til both teams are announced

Smith and Hall

[Ajax22]

1 of Bugg or Ellis or Morris

2 of Magner, Coniglio and Shiel

1 of Giles or Redden

2 of D. Smith, Hall, Smedts and Dickson

Bugg
Magnet, Coniglio
Giles assuming no Brogan or Renouf
Smith, Hall

[mezzoculo]

Bugg - runs on the board

Magner and Coniglio - Shiel looked the least likely of the three (easrly days yet)

Giles - no vest chance

D. Smith and Dickson - managed high scores in the preseason and should settle after his initiation into the big league last weekend.

[felsty]

Two of Bugg, Ellis, Morris, Mohr
Three of Magner, Coniglio, Shiel, Ledger
Two of Kennedy, Smith, Hall, Dickson

[Ziplock]

bugg mohr
magner coniglio
kennedy smith


when in doubt, go the giants :P

[Ajax22]

bugg mohr
magner coniglio
kennedy smith


when in doubt, go the giants :P

+1 giants are all proven over the other options tho I'd contemplate Ellis over Mohr, maybe not this week tho
Oh and add Ledger to that midfield over Shiel

[henry]

Devon smith, jeremy cameron or billie smedts?

Smith or shiel? Bare in mind smith can only play in one possy

[Football Factory]

Devon smith, jeremy cameron or billie smedts?

Smith or shiel? Bare in mind smith can only play in one possy

Smith and Smith

[Ajax22]

Devon smith, jeremy cameron or billie smedts?

Smith or shiel? Bare in mind smith can only play in one possy

I assume you mean that you can swap Devon Smith into the midfield and hence choose between him and Shiel aswell right?

If so then Devon Smith in the forwards and Shiel on the midfield. Shiel will only get better as he regains fitness and Devon Smith is a gun.

If you meant Clay Smith in the mids then yea play him over Shiel. But I would back Shiel over Smedts and Cameron if thats your issue

[crabapples]

No talk bout c smith being subbed is that concerning anyone?

[Football Factory]

No talk bout c smith being subbed is that concerning anyone?

Na dont have him   :(    ... He pulled up sore .. bad cramp i think, should be ok and get better with more games