Will Magnet Play?

[Football Factory]

Putting it out there...he wont play

Go ahead and boo me but i have a gut feeling about this one.  I saw the injury...he tweaked it in qtr 2, and did a lot more than tweak in qtr 4....hobbled off (yes unassisted i know) and looked very sore. He is an amazeballs player and i want him to play but don't be surprised if Melb don't rush him back.  They are keeping it quiet in the press because he happened to be their best player last week...don't want to tell ur opposition they don't have to deal with him too early do ya??!!

I hope your wrong  .. gonna maybe have to burn a trade otherwise   :'(

[The Grundles]

why would you burn a trade its only rnd 2? and maggers is a certain keeper

[Football Factory]

why would you burn a trade its only rnd 2? and maggers is a certain keeper

lol  .. as if i would trade Maggers   ::)   ... If Shiela dont get named Macca suspended Magner injured = donut   :P

[The Grundles]

ahh right ;)

Shiel will be named for sure...he will come good

[Football Factory]

ahh right ;)

Shiel will be named for sure...he will come good

This time i hope your right  :)

[elephants]

why would you burn a trade its only rnd 2? and maggers is a certain keeper

lol  .. as if i would trade Maggers   ::)   ... If Shiela dont get named Macca suspended Magner injured = donut   :P

In that case I would trade McDonald and then get him back when he is on the bubble :)

[Football Factory]

why would you burn a trade its only rnd 2? and maggers is a certain keeper

lol  .. as if i would trade Maggers   ::)   ... If Shiela dont get named Macca suspended Magner injured = donut   :P

In that case I would trade McDonald and then get him back when he is on the bubble :)

This would be worst case scenario  :'(     really dont want to trade any of them .. C.Smith looks alright tho

[picker_man]

why would you burn a trade its only rnd 2? and maggers is a certain keeper

lol  .. as if i would trade Maggers   ::)   ... If Shiela dont get named Macca suspended Magner injured = donut   :P

In that case I would trade McDonald and then get him back when he is on the bubble :)

This would be worst case scenario  :'(     really dont want to trade any of them .. C.Smith looks alright tho

i might have to trade mcdonald aswell dont wanna cop a donut so early

[The Grundles]

Please see other thread but Magner is listed as indefinite

http://www.injuryupdate.com.au/afl-melbourne-demons-injury-list.php

[Football Factory]

My brain hurts

[owenbond007]

I reckon i would rather take more notice of the afl site:

http://www.afl.com.au/injury%20list/tabid/17684/default.aspx

Last updated today, bit more official.

[Justin Bieber]

I'm backing coniglio. Although should I play magner over clay smith?

[Ajax22]

Magner over Smith any day of the week

Magners an absolute weapon although admittedly in a shocking team.

Smiths score was somewhat inflated due to the four goals. He won't kick that every week

[Ricochet]

Magner over Smith any day of the week

Magners an absolute weapon although admittedly in a shocking team.

Smiths score was somewhat inflated due to the four goals. He won't kick that every week

??????? yeh but he won't get severe cramp every week and get subbed off either...

[Ajax22]

Magner over Smith any day of the week

Magners an absolute weapon although admittedly in a shocking team.

Smiths score was somewhat inflated due to the four goals. He won't kick that every week

??????? yeh but he won't get severe cramp every week and get subbed off either...

Don't get me wrong, loving the kid and think he'll score well I just don't think hes at Magners standard. Magner looks like the dominant rookie early on this year