Back rookies and prems

[Haddy1.0]

Who should I pick out of the 2 rooks?
They've both been named in the back pocket but I'm not sure who I should pick or is there better options out there? (please name).
I already have Miller, Ellis and Clarke.

Also can't choose between Broughts and Shaw. I'm liking the fact that Broughts has been named in the middle but as soon as I got him last year he burnt me. How long will he be in the middle for? Shaw seems to be able to smash out some big numbers at times but is he consistent?
Cheers in advance for your votes and comments.

[Justin Bieber]

Lol I could vote for Smedts and Boumann if I wanted ;D

[Madsnake]

Lol I could vote for Smedts and Boumann if I wanted ;D

....Wouldn't that be hilarious  ???

[Justin Bieber]

Lol I could vote for Smedts and Boumann if I wanted ;D

....Wouldn't that be hilarious  ???

lol

[mezzoculo]

I would also consider Paine from the Pies ($98k DEF/FWD).

[Haddy1.0]

Yes you could if you were 12  ;D

[Justin Bieber]

Smedts and shaw.

[stew42]

Although out of Broughts and Shaw, Broughts has the higher ceiling

[Haddy1.0]

Should I maybe have Broughts and Shaw then and take out Heppell?

[Justin Bieber]

Should I maybe have Broughts and Shaw then and take out Heppell?

Yes good idea  ;D

[stew42]

I've put in Broughts over Hep D.

[Cam DM]

Smedts gotta be better, Hawks have a few options for Boumann's position down back like Gilham.

Gotta love Broughts playing mid and can still rack up off half back when Mundy's back. Can Shaw resist the pint and the punt? Not convinced.

[Haddy1.0]

Sorry to go a bit off topic here, I think I've made my mind up with the backs.
Is Clay Smith from the dogs worth a spot? Or can you name any other good rook mids except ledger (a bit on the pricey side)

[Justin Bieber]

He's starting in the middle. So I guess he may go well. I have him ;D