S.Thompson, Fyfe, Danger and Def Rookie vs Boyd, Martin, Porp and Marty Clarke

[Romulus]

Doing some tinkering just wondering peoples thoughts on a couple of combos.

Scotty Thompson has been in and out of my team and have just recently felt like jumping on the Boyd bandwagon.
Is Martin a must have? is Fyfe a must have?

Option 1. S. Thompson, Fyfe, Danger and Def Rookie (already have morris, ellis, bugg)

Option 2. Boyd, Martin, Porpoise and Marty.

[Justin Bieber]

Wow I thought Fyfe, Boyd and Martin are all locks...

[Romulus]

I made the fail of choosing Goodes over Fyfe so can't really afford Martin and Fyfe now. Is Fyfe still gonna pump out big scores when not 100% fit? (Yes he had an awesome last nab game). I didn't want to jump on the Boyd bandwagon but bloody every team and his cat has Boyd so could fall behind the pack if Thommo loses some points to Van Berlo and Sloane and Co.

I guess is it more important to have Boyd or Fyfe?

Thompson < Boyd
Fyfe > Martin
Danger > Porp (?)
Def Rook < Marty Clarke

Sidebum could make way for Fyfe too actually but I like Mr Sidebottom.

[Justin Bieber]

Fyfe is fit? What are you talking about? He has played well in several NAB cup games.

[Romulus]

What are you talking about didn't Fyfey battle a shoulder reconstruction and groin surgery in the off-season? He could well be fully fit by now and the nab games seem to suggest this but I haven't put him to LOCK status because of this.

Edit: Ok I have now bitten the bullet and put in both Boyd and Fyfe at the expense of Scotty Thompson and Sidebum

[Ricochet]

That report on Fyfe not being fully fit was like 3 weeks ago. He would have easily caught up fitness by now