Swan vs. Pendles

[Bak2Form]

poll currently locked at 15 each... doesnt really help u 2 much lol

It helps plenty, it says GET BOTH!

i got both ;)

[Alka]

I think people are picking Pendles mostly for the extra 20k, as it's very hard to differentiate the two. I'm in two minds about it, but at the end of the day I can put that 20k to good use elsewhere.

[lollipop man]

I'm going Swan simply because i have nothing to put the $20k to. But does anyone know why his NAB scores were so low?? I think he played more than 80% game time in all but one of his games.

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

I'm going Swan simply because i have nothing to put the $20k to. But does anyone know why his NAB scores were so low?? I think he played more than 80% game time in all but one of his games.

he does not give a shiz about the NAB hahaha :)

[mezzoculo]

I'm going Swan simply because i have nothing to put the $20k to. But does anyone know why his NAB scores were so low?? I think he played more than 80% game time in all but one of his games.

he does not give a shiz about the NAB hahaha :)

Another reason is that Pendles is more suited to Buckley's game style than Swan...

I heard Dermott (or another talking head) on SEN say that the Pies were playing more 'corridor football' during the preseason than under Malthouse. Their defenders were looking for Pendles and Sidebottom (I think) to use their high accuracy by foot hit targets running through the centre square.

The Pies' previous game plan (boundary line and stoppages) suited Swan, as he was able to use his tank to hit packs and pick up those DT-friendly kick-mark-kick combos as the ball moved from stoppage to stoppage along the flanks.

Just a thought.

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

I'm going Swan simply because i have nothing to put the $20k to. But does anyone know why his NAB scores were so low?? I think he played more than 80% game time in all but one of his games.

he does not give a shiz about the NAB hahaha :)

Another reason is that Pendles is more suited to Buckley's game style than Swan...

I heard Dermott (or another talking head) on SEN say that the Pies were playing more 'corridor football' during the preseason than under Malthouse. Their defenders were looking for Pendles and Sidebottom (I think) to use their high accuracy by foot hit targets running through the centre square.

The Pies' previous game plan (boundary line and stoppages) suited Swan, as he was able to use his tank to hit packs and pick up those DT-friendly kick-mark-kick combos as the ball moved from stoppage to stoppage along the flanks.

Just a thought.

new coach could mean the downfall of dreamteam's most powerful unit!

but i doubt it  ;D good point mezz!

[Windigo]

Swan-->Pendlebury-->Boyd-->Swan.

Couldn't decide. So I've gone back to my original pick and just get him from the start.

[its me lads]

i had swan then got pendles then swan again cos he is such a gun how can you ingnore him.