Swan vs. Pendles

[lollipop man]

I have a feeling Pendles is going to win the poll but really don't know why people would go him over Swan.

[elephants]

Pendles for me. Super consistent, maybe even more settled now he has his contract.

My problem is Murphy + 40k or Swan though...

[Jukes]

Swan > Every other player in history at DT.

Nobody will rival Swan for that number 1 average until he retires.

Pendles is consistent around his average, but Swanny is often and at points (eg early on and after Arizona 2012) consistent around 150.

[elephants]

Swan > Every other player in history at DT.

Nobody will rival Swan for that number 1 average until he retires.

Pendles is consistent around his average, but Swanny is often and at points (eg early on and after Arizona 2012) consistent around 150.

This. Is it then worth picking him after Arizona??

[Holz]

i couldn't decide who not to start  between the 2 so i got both, but if i had to drop someone it would definitely be Pendles.

[Zombie2.5]

Swan > Every other player in history at DT.

Nobody has rivalled Swan for that number 1 average until he retires YET.

Pendles is consistent around his average, but Swanny is often and at points (eg early on and after Arizona 2012) consistent around 150.

Pendles is fast catching up and Gablett, boyd and other super premiums are also up there.
The younger stars e.g. selwood, pendles again, gibbs etc. might catch up when they mature more too.

Swan still wants to go to Arizona again so imo better for Post-bye upgrade.
Pendles FTW!
Btw my premo mids are Pendles, Boyd, Gablett, Redden

And pendles will only get better of course, hes only 24 me thinks, his best is still ahead of him.

[elephants]

Well said ^^

Currently have Pendles, Boyd, Gazza and Murphy.

Murphy cold be any of Selwood, Thompson, Rocky, Redden, Mitchell even?? Come Friday night...

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

I'd go pendles simply cuz that 22k can be used elsewhere ;D it fits my structure perfectly! I only have $100 left LOL!

[Jukes]

Guys, put it this way. How will you feel when you log into your dt on a Sunday morning and see a juicy 330 next to your opponents captain. Now imagine seeing that in all 5 games. That will happen a lot if you don't pick up Swanny from the get go.

[Phasir]

Pendles for me, said it all pre-season, sticking with the champ :)

[Holz]

Pendles for me, said it all pre-season, sticking with the champ :)

if your sticking with the champ surely that means your going swan.

[Phasir]

nah, he comes in after round 12 to help with my doughnut evasion tactis ;)

[Bak2Form]

poll currently locked at 15 each... doesnt really help u 2 much lol

[Romulus]

poll currently locked at 15 each... doesnt really help u 2 much lol

It helps plenty, it says GET BOTH!

[locknload]

Pendles is more of a Supercoach player.
Dane Swan is THE DT Player.
Swan and Boyd would be my top two mids.