Calling all GUN coaches :)

TMurphBROWNLOW · March 28, 2012, 08:39:04 PM

I need some help all you fellow, trustworthy fan-footy dreamteamers :D

Option 1: Fyfe + Dangerfield + Porplyzia + DPP link

VS

Option 2: Boyd + Martin + Kerridge + No DPP link

Option 1
the way i see it is the DPP link isn't all that important this year as it was last. fyfe is a gun who should score 80-120, week in, week out. his selection should be a no-brainer unless you're having difficulty finding the money (which i obviously am :P). dangerfield has the potential to get into that fyfe, beams, zaha category if he slays it during the season proper (going from his amazing NAB form). i really like and rate the kid although he is chosen by a few too many hundred people :/ scoring-wise? 70-110. porplyzia is as safe as nails... JS-wise! ;) body wise... we all know he could end his season if he tries to bench more than 40kg :P apart from that he is a proven 70-90 scorer but he has burnt me in the past. (not a happy chappy).

Option 2
despite no DPP link, the team looks absolutely superb! boyd is possibly the best DT-er in the competition. while swan and pendlebury were taking the NAB less than seriously, boyd absolutely killed it and was the top DT-er of the series. he has the capacity to score the high 140s and even have 'shocking' scores of mid 90s. absolute superstar. dusty has a pretty tough draw and that's why i'm reluctant to pick him. he's a super player though and will eventually be in my top 7 fwds, and i have a feeling he will play very well even though the draw would tend to differ otherwise! based on the draw i can see him averaging 70-110. kerridge will make me some money ;D if named that is, which i'm sure he will! the money that he makes will be beneficial in the long run, and i can see him scoring anywhere between 40-80 :)

Verdict
I HAVE NO IDEA :P i just need people's opinions on this final dilemma! Thank You in Advance :)

Scrads · March 28, 2012, 08:57:41 PM

I would say option 2 personally, although there are probably better/safer options than Kerridge for the rookie spot. (Hall, Dickson, Couch)

Jukes · March 28, 2012, 09:00:00 PM

Option 2 by a fair bit imo. In 1 you're getting 1 premium, an upper mid-pricer (with potential, mind you) and an injury plagued but advanced rookie. In 2 you get 2 super premiums and a rookie.

Basically 2 premiums vs 1.

Ziplock · March 28, 2012, 09:02:52 PM

Quote from: TMurphBROWNLOW on March 28, 2012, 08:39:04 PM
I need some help all you fellow, trustworthy fan-footy dreamteamers :D

Option 1: Fyfe + Dangerfield + Porplyzia + DPP link

VS

Option 2: Boyd + Martin + Kerridge + No DPP link

Option 1
the way i see it is the DPP link isn't all that important this year as it was last. fyfe is a gun who should score 80-120, week in, week out. his selection should be a no-brainer unless you're having difficulty finding the money (which i obviously am :P). dangerfield has the potential to get into that fyfe, beams, zaha category if he slays it during the season proper (going from his amazing NAB form). i really like and rate the kid although he is chosen by a few too many hundred people :/ scoring-wise? 70-110. porplyzia is as safe as nails... JS-wise! ;) body wise... we all know he could end his season if he tries to bench more than 40kg :P apart from that he is a proven 70-90 scorer but he has burnt me in the past. (not a happy chappy).

Option 2
despite no DPP link, the team looks absolutely superb! boyd is possibly the best DT-er in the competition. while swan and pendlebury were taking the NAB less than seriously, boyd absolutely killed it and was the top DT-er of the series. he has the capacity to score the high 140s and even have 'shocking' scores of mid 90s. absolute superstar. dusty has a pretty tough draw and that's why i'm reluctant to pick him. he's a super player though and will eventually be in my top 7 fwds, and i have a feeling he will play very well even though the draw would tend to differ otherwise! based on the draw i can see him averaging 70-110. kerridge will make me some money ;D if named that is, which i'm sure he will! the money that he makes will be beneficial in the long run, and i can see him scoring anywhere between 40-80 :)

Verdict
I HAVE NO IDEA :P i just need people's opinions on this final dilemma! Thank You in Advance :)

boyd combo. Martin will outscore danger, boyd outscore fyfe, porps and a rookie (if you pick the right one, not necessarily kerridge) could hypothetically score similar.

Boyd- 115, Martin- 100, rookie- 65= 280
Fyfe- 100 (max imo), danger- 90, porps 80- 270

these are best case scenarios as well. Danger is far more likely to average sub 80 that martin is to average sub 90, fyfe more likely to average under 100 than boyd is to average under 115, porps will probably outscore the majority of rookies by about 10-15 though.

easy one imo :P

TMurphBROWNLOW · March 28, 2012, 09:17:21 PM

I've gone with 2 ;D thanks guys! you all get cheers 8)

Ziplock · March 28, 2012, 09:20:23 PM

goodo pushes me to 190

who wants to take it to 200? :P

TMurphBROWNLOW · March 28, 2012, 09:23:23 PM

i'll help every hour if you keep the excellent advice coming ;)

going couch over kerridge also allowed me to go pavlich -> fyfe! YAY! so happy right now :')

Justin Bieber · March 28, 2012, 09:25:08 PM

Yeah Murphs, Dusty Marts is lock, same as Boyd. Maybe get someone better than Kerridge and it will looks great.

Tom_16 · March 28, 2012, 09:31:11 PM

Quote from: Ziplock on March 28, 2012, 09:02:52 PM
Quote from: TMurphBROWNLOW on March 28, 2012, 08:39:04 PM
I need some help all you fellow, trustworthy fan-footy dreamteamers :D

Option 1: Fyfe + Dangerfield + Porplyzia + DPP link

VS

Option 2: Boyd + Martin + Kerridge + No DPP link

Option 1
the way i see it is the DPP link isn't all that important this year as it was last. fyfe is a gun who should score 80-120, week in, week out. his selection should be a no-brainer unless you're having difficulty finding the money (which i obviously am :P). dangerfield has the potential to get into that fyfe, beams, zaha category if he slays it during the season proper (going from his amazing NAB form). i really like and rate the kid although he is chosen by a few too many hundred people :/ scoring-wise? 70-110. porplyzia is as safe as nails... JS-wise! ;) body wise... we all know he could end his season if he tries to bench more than 40kg :P apart from that he is a proven 70-90 scorer but he has burnt me in the past. (not a happy chappy).

Option 2
despite no DPP link, the team looks absolutely superb! boyd is possibly the best DT-er in the competition. while swan and pendlebury were taking the NAB less than seriously, boyd absolutely killed it and was the top DT-er of the series. he has the capacity to score the high 140s and even have 'shocking' scores of mid 90s. absolute superstar. dusty has a pretty tough draw and that's why i'm reluctant to pick him. he's a super player though and will eventually be in my top 7 fwds, and i have a feeling he will play very well even though the draw would tend to differ otherwise! based on the draw i can see him averaging 70-110. kerridge will make me some money ;D if named that is, which i'm sure he will! the money that he makes will be beneficial in the long run, and i can see him scoring anywhere between 40-80 :)

Verdict
I HAVE NO IDEA :P i just need people's opinions on this final dilemma! Thank You in Advance :)
boyd combo. Martin will outscore danger, boyd outscore fyfe, porps and a rookie (if you pick the right one, not necessarily kerridge) could hypothetically score similar.

Boyd- 115, Martin- 100, rookie- 65= 280
Fyfe- 100 (max imo), danger- 90, porps 80- 270

these are best case scenarios as well. Danger is far more likely to average sub 80 that martin is to average sub 90, fyfe more likely to average under 100 than boyd is to average under 115, porps will probably outscore the majority of rookies by about 10-15 though.

easy one imo :P

Not a big fan of fyfe ziplock? may i ask why?

kilbluff1985 · March 28, 2012, 09:38:21 PM

Quote from: Ziplock on March 28, 2012, 09:20:23 PM
goodo pushes me to 190

who wants to take it to 200? :P

i'm bored why not lol

Bak2Form · March 29, 2012, 02:10:05 PM

option 2

Spite · March 29, 2012, 02:13:54 PM

Quote from: TMurphBROWNLOW on March 28, 2012, 09:23:23 PM
i'll help every hour if you keep the excellent advice coming ;)

going couch over kerridge also allowed me to go pavlich -> fyfe! YAY! so happy right now :')

Its funny how that happens. Can I have your $100 spare? I am $100 short of Pendles :'(

TMurphBROWNLOW · March 29, 2012, 02:54:46 PM

Quote from: Spite on March 29, 2012, 02:13:54 PM
Quote from: TMurphBROWNLOW on March 28, 2012, 09:23:23 PM
i'll help every hour if you keep the excellent advice coming ;)

going couch over kerridge also allowed me to go pavlich -> fyfe! YAY! so happy right now :')

Its funny how that happens. Can I have your $100 spare? I am $100 short of Pendles :'(

I'll send it over through email ;) perhaps go Boyd? unless you already have him!