Couch upgraded

[ENYGMA]

Taking Hall out for Couch defs.

My forward rooks are D. Smith, A. Kennedy (both locked), then benched is Hall and Dickson. I think Dickson will get more vests than Hall but I don't think Hall will hit his preseason numbers.

Hall or Dickson out for Couch?  :-\

[Ricochet]

Taking Hall out for Couch defs.

My forward rooks are D. Smith, A. Kennedy (both locked), then benched is Hall and Dickson. I think Dickson will get more vests than Hall but I don't think Hall will hit his preseason numbers.

Hall or Dickson out for Couch?  :-\

I have the same problem. ATM i have taken out Dickson for Couch but will wait to see where the 3 are named when teams come out

[pavs nose]

locked him in eddie. although i hope he debuts round 2 so kennedys score counts for me

+1 I'm hoping for that to happen so much, need either him or Hall to miss the first round or I'll miss out :(

looks like we got our wish there phasir. no couch rnd 1

[pinochio]

locked him in eddie. although i hope he debuts round 2 so kennedys score counts for me

+1 I'm hoping for that to happen so much, need either him or Hall to miss the first round or I'll miss out :(

looks like we got our wish there phasir. no couch rnd 1

you guys think its worth it??? starting couch on field??

[pavs nose]

@pinochio - i'm pretty confident. part of the reason behind this my belief that brisbane will beat melbourne this week by flogging them in the midfield. then couch will come in the following week as a knee jerk reaction by neald, play well and secure his spot  8)

well....that is the plan anyway

[sledgey7]

how is everybody so excited over a guy whose coach doesn't even think he's good eough to play rnd 1 just because he's 85k?

I say be wary. i'm keeping hall and ignoring the hype for now (unless he scores 2 tons in his first 2 games)

hopefully he doesn't play for a few weeks and could even make it to downgrade territory.

[Artax]

how is everybody so excited over a guy whose coach doesn't even think he's good eough to play rnd 1 just because he's 85k?

I say be wary. i'm keeping hall and ignoring the hype for now (unless he scores 2 tons in his first 2 games)

hopefully he doesn't play for a few weeks and could even make it to downgrade territory.

+1

Have kept both Hall and Dickson over this guy

[Holz]

how is everybody so excited over a guy whose coach doesn't even think he's good eough to play rnd 1 just because he's 85k?

I say be wary. i'm keeping hall and ignoring the hype for now (unless he scores 2 tons in his first 2 games)

hopefully he doesn't play for a few weeks and could even make it to downgrade territory.

+1

Have kept both Hall and Dickson over this guy

i would too but, had to get rid of gray and needed the money. I would rather a rookie not playing, than a premium

[Phasir]

locked him in eddie. although i hope he debuts round 2 so kennedys score counts for me

+1 I'm hoping for that to happen so much, need either him or Hall to miss the first round or I'll miss out :(

looks like we got our wish there phasir. no couch rnd 1

"Oh Yeaarh" (duffman style) :P

[Ricochet]

how is everybody so excited over a guy whose coach doesn't even think he's good eough to play rnd 1 just because he's 85k?

I say be wary. i'm keeping hall and ignoring the hype for now (unless he scores 2 tons in his first 2 games)

hopefully he doesn't play for a few weeks and could even make it to downgrade territory.

+1

Have kept both Hall and Dickson over this guy

i would too but, had to get rid of gray and needed the money. I would rather a rookie not playing, than a premium

+1 exactly. what if couch doesnt get a game for a while? I've brought dickson back in for couch and now have him and Hall on the bench

[pavs nose]

how is everybody so excited over a guy whose coach doesn't even think he's good eough to play rnd 1 just because he's 85k?

I say be wary. i'm keeping hall and ignoring the hype for now (unless he scores 2 tons in his first 2 games)

hopefully he doesn't play for a few weeks and could even make it to downgrade territory.

+1

Have kept both Hall and Dickson over this guy

i would too but, had to get rid of gray and needed the money. I would rather a rookie not playing, than a premium

+1 exactly. what if couch doesnt get a game for a while? I've brought dickson back in for couch and now have him and Hall on the bench

there are of what ifs in DT. He was promoted off the rookie list so that tells me they are strongly considering him for early games. This game is all about decisions. some pay off and some don't. if we all did the same things would not be very interesting would they.

[jabroni]

yeah everybody remembers when rockcliff wasnt named rd1 and a whole heap of ppl jumped off only to regret it later

couch is mature aged and promoted off the rookie list. Melb named Josh Tynan who i dont think will get a lot of games being 18/19 and not very bulked so couch might come in when hes out

[pinochio]

so whats the play fellas???

seems 50/50 on what to do???

[jamesalex]

so whats the play fellas???

seems 50/50 on what to do???

Yeah i'm 50/50. If I get Couch, he gives me DPP in the midfield. But if he is'nt named, I could have a problem considering I have McDonald on the pine.

[pinochio]

+ the added bonus of kennedys score!

so hard :(