Closing in on my final team, pleasecomment

[Noddy5]

Def....

C Yarran, G Broughton, B Goddard, P Davis, T Mohr, B Ellis, B Lake, L Spurr, G Guthrie

Mid....

T Rockliff, S Pendlebury, G Ablett, J Caddy, J Selwood, S Coniglio, T Ledger, J Magner

Ruck...

I Maric, N Naitanui, J Giles, J Redden

Forwards....

P Dangerfield, N Fyfe, A Hall, D Smith, L Franklin, A Saad, A Goodes, D Zorko, J Cripps

Please be critical!!!! And give advice

Thanks

[felsty]

You seem to have a lot of players in the mid - premium price range without getting the guns, blokes like yarran, Davis, Guthrie on the bench, Marci, nicnat, Cripps.. Think some should be downgraded and some need to be upgraded
I count 9 guns, that's including Broughton who is up and down! Most teams have 13-14 proven guns in them.. You will burn a lot of trades upgrading mid pricers to guns, much better off gettin them in now so you can save trades for later!

[Noddy5]

From all the reports I'm getting, Yarran is expected to explode this season.

[felsty]

If that's the case 3 premium back, 4 mids, 0 rucks, 3 forwards.. Most sides have a 5-4-1-5 or 4-4-2-4. I suggest you try and get some tried and true sc players in.. I'm not saying don't go for the players you want to take a gamble on, but maybe only have a few you choose, ATM it's too much risk and not enough premiums to rip out a big score

[Noddy5]

Would love some suggestions if you have any

[felsty]

C Yarran, G Broughton, B Goddard, P Davis, T Mohr, B Ellis, B Lake, L Spurr, G Guthrie
T Rockliff, S Pendlebury, G Ablett, J Caddy, J Selwood, S Coniglio, T Ledger, J Magner
I Maric, N Naitanui, J Giles, J Redden
P Dangerfield, N Fyfe, A Hall, D Smith, L Franklin, A Saad, A Goodes, D Zorko, J Cripps

Backs I would upgrade Davis to Deledio or shaw. Downgrade Guthrie to a rookie priced rookie. Plenty out there, boumann, Morris
Mids are good! If you need money downgrade caddy..
Rucks you need either cox or Mumford, downgrade one and upgrade the other
Good but could maybe use another premium, chapman or Martin?
To do these upgrades I would downgrade Guthrie Cripps maybe caddy?
Back is your first priority then rucks

[tor01doc]

Noddy5

Post your players in order each line from $$$ to $.
Makes it much easier to get a read on your team.

At the moment I agree with Mr Felsty.

Middling priced risky players without SC pedigree are going to cost you plenty of trades.

Pendlebury too much to start with.

Get Cox now that you've missed Mumford.

Ablett and Selwood are great.

Yarran / Davis / Lake / Guthrie - 2 have to go

Caddy or the 4th mid a luxury I don't think you can afford with Coniglio in.

A Hall? What do you know about him?

Zorko injured so get him later.

Cripps is a bit pricey so look for $$ here too if needed.

[lowry]

nice choice of mid priced and unique players, hope they pay off for you!  ;D

[Noddy5]

How do you feel about D Swallow

[tor01doc]

Nope.

Try and get minimum 12 keepers - ie > about $500K.

Swallow might be a good player but not sure about SC.

Maybe post a thread under players etc and see.

[eagles929406]

nic nat is a good unique and will av a lot more this year nice choice

[Noddy5]

Any forwards you can recommend?

[felsty]

Premiums or rookies??

[Noddy5]

Both..... Preferably rookies

[pavs nose]

good side. i'd go zorko to couch now that couch is off the rookie list