Collingwood Newbies

Started by Binga, March 27, 2012, 09:17:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Binga

Read today that Yagmoor, PAine and Witts may be making their debuts this weekend, people's thoughts?

Pretty keen on Witts as I'm going 4 rookie rucks.

Justin Bieber

What about Marty Clarke?

News on him Binga?

roti

4 rookie rucks whaaaaaaaaaat. ive got 3 and im nervous.

looks like clarkes place might be in trouble with yagmoor, but it said he was in line for a recall

Ziplock

I've got 3, but I'm not nervous :P

cant see witts holding down his spot- was absolutely dominated in NAB rucking against giles from memory.

Binga

#4
yeah though Clarke is not making his debut, I'd say between him and Yagmoor. Paine could fit be in and out of the side this year.
Witts, competing with Wood for second ruck.

Quote from: roti on March 27, 2012, 09:24:02 PM
4 rookie rucks whaaaaaaaaaat. ive got 3 and im nervous.
Yeapp, it is the way to go, Backline and forwards absolutely loaded! I make up not fielding rookies in those positions by having them in the ruck. Figured Premium rucks score the least out of all premiums and most likely to miss games through injury. Its risky but I'm willing to take it.

Quote from: Ziplock on March 27, 2012, 09:25:21 PM
I've got 3, but I'm not nervous :P

cant see witts holding down his spot- was absolutely dominated in NAB rucking against giles from memory.
Yeah he probs won't but I figured I don't really need him to play. Combiined 100 points from my starting rucks each week and I benefit significantly from the risk.

underdog11

Na Clarke has Johnson's spot for now

Ziplock

I went hmac as first ruck, still lots of cash to splash, but just that much safer.

Binga

Quote from: underdog11 on March 27, 2012, 09:31:43 PM
Na Clarke has Johnson's spot for now
Forgot about that, well picked up on. Is Didak playing round 1?

underdog11

Quote from: Ziplock on March 27, 2012, 09:34:06 PM
I went hmac as first ruck, still lots of cash to splash, but just that much safer.

Finally someone who is going with the H-Mac, although a bit hypocritical that i couldn't slot him into my own side  :-\

sid3bysid3

Dont think h Mac will produce with goldy. Nab form was only old when goldy rested. G Is a better ruckman

Zombie2.5

Hmm, not sure but i think C'woods defense is in trouble, maxy is ruled out and some others not playing.
Im not sure whos out actually and if they are key positions or not, but just saying their defense has some holes right now.

Binga

Quote from: Zombie2.5 on March 27, 2012, 10:47:15 PM
Hmm, not sure but i think C'woods defense is in trouble, maxy is ruled out and some others not playing.
Im not sure whos out actually and if they are key positions or not, but just saying their defense has some holes right now.

Ben Reid under an injury cloud?