Montagna or Cotchin?

[boneman]

Which one as M4...Please leave comments.

Montagna - Still averaged 101 last year in an injury interrupted season. 24 disposal average. More uncontested possessions. Comes at a nice price and a new coach may recapture his old form of previous seasons where he averaged 126 and 115. Will share the midfield and points with Dal Santo, Goddard, Hayes and some new kids (Ledger & Steven).

Already have - Goddard

Cotchin - Averaged 101 last season in his best year to date. 24 disposal average but managed 30 disposals in 3 games two of those games against Geelong and Collingwood. More contested possessions. Will share the midfield and points with Deledio, Martin, Foley and Tuck.

Already have - Deledio, Ellis, Morris and Martin

My starting Mids - Ablett, Boyd, Selwood, Shiel, Pfeiffer/Magner

[boneman]

Only 7 votes c'mon guys!  ???

Someone has started a similar thread here on Montagna

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,53111.0.html

But nobody has really made comment on the possibilities of Cotchin as a Premium Mid.