Is it worth fitting S. Thommo in the mids for Ablett/Selwood?

Started by Dave085, March 26, 2012, 10:57:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Is it worth popping S. Thompson in the mids and replace Ablett or Selwood

Yes, replace Ablett
4 (14.8%)
Yes, replace Selwood
9 (33.3%)
Why would you do that you clown!?
14 (51.9%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Dave085

Gday guys,

Every year I look at S. Thompson and say, man, why didnt you put him in. I guess in the last few years he would be a unique, at least in the leagues ive been in.

So im thinking this year, shall I put Thommo in? I can simply side swap him for J. Selwood, or pocket a few extra bucks and replace Ablett.

But the question i ask, do you think im a clown for thinking this or would it be a good move? Thompson could be in for an improved DT year with new coach and strategies, or, could Dangerfield take something away from him? I dont know, thats why im putting it out there and asking the experts  :P

Pendles, Boyd, Ablett, Selwood, Coniglio, D. Smith    - Magner, Shiel.

Dave.

Holz

if you can use the money very effectively to improve your team do it, if not keep it how it is.

Artax

Similar dilemna.. I have the exact same midfield although I have Scotty already I just don't have Boyd.

This is the first season I have not started with Boyd and I am debating do I drop Pendles for Boyd?

Scotty will kill it but I don't know if it's worth dropping Jelwood...definately not Ablett

Justin Bieber


Dave085

Had to edit initial post, I fell short by $5k of the "slight upgrade" i was planning on.

So far it seems like i be the clown...

Jukes


stew42

My mid elites are Swan Pendles Boyd and GAJ.

Gee it's nice not to have problems!

Alka

Quote from: Jukes on March 27, 2012, 01:01:34 AM
Ablett > Thompson > Selwood

This.

Selwood can be upgraded to later. With Thommo's nice draw you want him in early.

Artax


stew42


Cicjose


Artax

Can afford to have Boyd over Selwood only if I downgrade Danger to Porps

Holz

Quote from: Artax on March 27, 2012, 02:48:02 AM
Can afford to have Boyd over Selwood only if I downgrade Danger to Porps

definitely not worth it i think there wil be 5 points max difference in boy and selwood , danger will get alot more than that over porp.