Natinui or Jacobs or Minson

Started by bkp130, March 26, 2012, 10:04:31 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which one for the R2 spot

Natinui
6 (33.3%)
Jacobs
8 (44.4%)
Minson
4 (22.2%)

Total Members Voted: 1

bkp130

Thanks for your vote. Im unsure who to have as my second ruck

MC

Easily Nic Nat of those options! More ruck time and will easily average 100+

HotTiges

reckon NicNat is a solid pick but think Jacobs will be a very good pick and POD as no one rates him on here.. wouldn't consider big willis but he may surprise.

Ringo

Jacobs will be surprise this year imo and being the No 1 Ruck at Adelaide this year he may be the Leuenberger of 2012.

Minson was also very solid in the NAB cup and may also be worth a shot.

Still not convinced on Nic Nat durability and partnership with Cox effecting his scores

All three though will be solid second Ruck picks but if you have Cox as first pick then bear in mind all 3 have a Round 11 bye as well which will be significant if you have Giles as well.