Guthrie vs. Clark at D6??

Started by Dons.Man, March 26, 2012, 04:04:30 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who would you pick?

Guthrie
7 (41.2%)
Clark
10 (58.8%)

Total Members Voted: 2

Dons.Man

Tossing up between these two as D6, leaning towards Clark atm. What do people think of their JS and scoring ability/consistency?

Colliwobblers

guthrie a much better player clark has arguably much better JS so has to be clark unless Guthrie's JS is proven... tough call

yorgis


ubeaut

Both have questionable JS I reckon. Still waiting to hear(injuries aside) how Clarke gets a regular gig in the backs with Brown,Tarrant,Reid,Shaw,Toovey,O'Brien,Maxwell,Goldsack,Yagmoor,Young etc. Maxwell is captain and is a certain. O'Brien and Shaw will play before Clarke. That leaves three spots for the talls(Brown,Tarrant,Reid). He will play early with injuries but after that ??????????? Bench spot maybe? Sub a few times? He's fit as but still readjusting to the oval shaped ball. Can someone please convince me that he'll play enough games? Love to have that cheap back option.