The McDonald bump

Started by Tom_16, March 24, 2012, 11:52:02 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Justin Bieber

Quote from: TheMailman on March 25, 2012, 05:06:50 PM
Go onto bigfooty and complain there, you'll get the same answer

Here, I'll provide you a link

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/archive/index.php/t-331868.html

lol from 2007?

unceramonius

lol, like i said we will see during the season

if its a suspension now.....its a suspension for the eagirls as well.

there really isnt more to be said.   

Justin Bieber

Quote from: unceramonius on March 25, 2012, 05:15:35 PM
lol, like i said we will see during the season

if its a suspension now.....its a suspension for the eagirls as well.

there really isnt more to be said.   

I see what you did there   :o

TheMailman

Quote from: unceramonius on March 25, 2012, 05:15:35 PM
lol, like i said we will see during the season

if its a suspension now.....its a suspension for the eagirls as well.

there really isnt more to be said.   

Just run away and gtfo like aflfreak and dt_gun did.

Quite obviously this is a site for people with a brain

unceramonius

mailman, you coulda fooled me

obviously this is a site for tools who only pick players for dreamteam, but know absolutely nothing about the game

never once have i stated i want my team looked after, ive always said i wanted consistency.

why did the eagirls get off so many times last year for offences deemed untolerable ( head over the ball).  ill tell you why.

doing so would jeopardise top 4 and MONEY.  lets see if the same crap continues this year.  but ssssssssssssh dont talk about it.....lets keep it a secret lol

jabroni

#80
ur the idiot for posting in the wrong section - this discussion is about whether a cheap priced player will miss games for a bump - if it was some low scoring player like glass then no one would give a shower. Tin foil hat conspiracy theories go somewhere else


you want to talk AFL go to this sub section but clearly you have issues and not just with navigating the interwebz

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/board,13.0.html

m0nty

Our buddy Uncle Ramon gets a week's holiday. Let this be a lesson to us all.

fattony

hopefully he gets six weeks or so, that way i can downgrade one of my mid rookies to him  :P

Justin Bieber

Quote from: fattony on March 25, 2012, 06:20:12 PM
hopefully he gets six weeks or so, that way i can downgrade one of my mid rookies to him  :P
Yeah and all the people who thought it was the best decision to recruit, look silly  8)

Fireballz

Back on topic...

http://www.bigpondsport.com/six-lessons-from-the-sydney-derby/tabid/91/newsid/85898/default.aspx
"McDonald's first-quarter shirtfront on Parker was the type many, if not most, AFL fans will consider part of the game. The hit was not high, McDonald did not leave the ground, and the ball was in the vicinity, if not under Parker's control. However, few fans would be surprised if the match review panel decided otherwise, and if the bump costs McDonald a suspension, sympathy will be thin on the ground. The ex-Demon was a member of the three-man MRP which presided over a number of controversial decisions last year â€" most notably the three-match suspension handed to Melbourne's Jack Trengove for his tackle on Patrick Dangerfield."

Who knew? I have him in my team but I hope he gets 6 weeks now. Pure karma baby!

elephants

Woah that is pretty interesting!!

Surely he'd know the ruling well enough then...?

Ziplock

'it was not high'
'ball was in the vicinity'

he shouldn't get weeks. Even if he was part of the panel for dangers suspension, couldn't he have argued against it? (*note* I don't know how the MRP system works very well)

Noz

Will get the same treatment as Folau and Selwood will have a go at the MRP again and get fined $5000.

Chelskiman

I thought it was a great bump.  If this was the 80's or 90's we would all be treating him like a hero.  flowering person game we have now.  You should expect to get hit once in a while when playing footy, and if not then the sport isn't for you.

bomberboy0618

Quote from: Tom_16 on March 25, 2012, 03:45:53 PM
Quote from: unceramonius on March 25, 2012, 03:37:22 PM
Butt hurt fanboys will whinge at my comment, but the facts are the facts.....if McDonald played for west coast, he would be let off, no questions asked.
That's not how you spell Collingwood..
And McDonald isnt how you spell Chris Judd...