McDonald VS Shiel as M6 Rd.1

[Chelskiman]

Right, think I'm sorted.  Starting Bugg, Shiel, Smith and Kennedy as my GWS players.  Got McDonald as an EMG in the mids.  Time to hope for the best...

[pinochio]

why jmac over shiel on field chelskiman??

[Windigo]

Haha.  :P

If I was Sheedy I'd be looking at subbing Shiel out of the game at like half time. Only played a half of footy in a while.

It would be ludicrous to sub J-Mac in the very first game when most of their team are debutants. Why take out one of the select few who can run out a whole game and will be leading from the front in the first game.

There's my 10 cents.  ;)

[pinochio]

yup windigo i agree with you :)

shiel gonna where the E this round!!!

[essendon2]

Haha.  :P

If I was Sheedy I'd be looking at subbing Shiel out of the game at like half time. Only played a half of footy in a while.

It would be ludicrous to sub J-Mac in the very first game when most of their team are debutants. Why take out one of the select few who can run out a whole game and will be leading from the front in the first game.

There's my 10 cents.  ;)

+1

[Windigo]

yup windigo i agree with you :)

shiel gonna where the E this round!!!

If Shiel plays a full game and smashes 110+, while J_Mac does his hip at the center bounce..... Don't blame me.  :P

[Chelskiman]

I hate you all. :P

[pinochio]

sif u just said that :P

tbh i was thinking old mac b4 but had the jitters :)

[Holz]

im putting Magner on the field with Shiel emergency
that way there is less ways for it to stuff up

Same here, good move i think.

do you have another non gws rookie on the bench, waht if shiel comes out and gets 100?.

I would do the same thing but i only have GWS rookies and couch.

[Chelskiman]

sif u just said that :P

Sorry.  Pre lock-out stress has got to me. :(

[Windigo]

Too much expectation on Shiel. Hasn't played a NAB. So I'm not taking the chance on him starting at 6.

[Grazz]

The expectation is cause he can play windi, one half in the reserves last week and he's starting tonight. Could be subbed so on my bench this week.  ;)

[sledgey7]

Too much expectation on Shiel. Hasn't played a NAB. So I'm not taking the chance on him starting at 6.

+1

i would also like to start magner and have the E on a GWS but i want clay smith on the field and i'd be screwed if neither of them were named.

[lollipop man]

Shiel...no JMac... no Shiel. AAARGHH i can't decide!!

[pinochio]

jmac