McDonald VS Shiel as M6 Rd.1

[pinochio]

For everyone, since i think this is a question everyone is having ATM!!!

who to start, help everyone out ASAP...

52 minutes and coutning!!!

[Hitman3095]

I'm interested...

[Loose]

Normally Shiel but scared he might be the sub as he's had no preseason

[LEV]

id like to say shiel cause he;s a gun, but due to his preseason IMO he could get the red vest? i dont know, its so hard !!!!

[pinochio]

I KNOW FELLAS!!

its doing head in, mcdonald as the senior player will come to play, while shiel hasnt played a game vs seniors in his life but is a rare talent!!!


arg!! help!!

[essendon2]

Shiel is likely to be red vested!

have both, but have OldMac on your field! - he's the most experienced player and will step up, also will be getting a lot of the ball

[pinochio]

regretfully im thinking old mac tbh!!!

[Jukes]

I don't see McDonald scoring much. Shiel is a lot better.

[Chelskiman]

Can people please stop posting.  Once I think I've settled on someone another post pops up and it's back to sqaure one again! ARRGGHH!

[Windigo]

I'm starting 5 GWS.

Giles, Coniglio, Kennedy, Devon & J-Mac.

All should be netting 60.... :P

[pinochio]

whats ur reasoning for jmac over shiel, thats what everyone here wants to knwo :P

[Grazz]

MacDonald is risky on 2 fronts i think, hasnt had a good Nab ran with a few opponents and nobody knows how long or how often you are going to have him. In saying that he's cheap and will make coin but how much but a no from me went with Shiel and Smith

[TheHanger]

im putting Magner on the field with Shiel emergency
that way there is less ways for it to stuff up

[pinochio]

what if magner isnt named and shiel/mac score 80ish???

[Grazz]

im putting Magner on the field with Shiel emergency
that way there is less ways for it to stuff up

Same here, good move i think.