Marty clarke

[teatowel]

Currently got option 2 but leaning towards option 1

[Windigo]

Every one is scared off by Marty.

He'll get games with so many outs at the Pies currently. But is he worth to extra cash over say Ellis?

[Master Q]

I have him...

[teatowel]

Yea ellis is a no brainer, already in my side but dunno who to choose between morris and marty. If i pick marty i have to downgrade kennedy to mcdonald cause im like $700 short lol

[Windigo]

Ouch, that's gotta hurt.  :P

I have Morris as well as Ellis. Put Kennedy FWD?  ???

[teatowel]

smith, cameron, couch as fwd rookies.
Also picking marty clarke means i wont have cash to change couch to a playing rookie if couch isnt named.

Gosh darnit!
If i had like 10k more id be sweet lol.

Probs have to stick with option 2 cause i dont like the idea of hardly any cash in the bank

[Windigo]

Seems the most logical thing you can do currently.  ;)

[maccar86]

clarke should be a lock at that price

[Holz]

Every one is scared off by Marty.

He'll get games with so many outs at the Pies currently. But is he worth to extra cash over say Ellis?

not worth the cash over ellis but i think he is worth it over morris

[essendon2]

should we start Magner or McDonald?

[Windigo]

Is he worth it over Dazza P.

Can get Clarke if I downgrade Dazza>Hall?

should we start Magner or McDonald?

Macca.

[essendon2]

Bugg or Morris? :P

[Notorious P.I.G.]

Is he worth it over Dazza P.

Can get Clarke if I downgrade Dazza>Hall?

should we start Magner or McDonald?

Macca.

Sounds like Clarke could be a semi-keeper, at least for the first half of the season if he is getting constant games... I think its worth it, Pfeiffer has a few other new players competing with him for games (McCarthy, Wingard, Gray moving into mids?) whereas if Hall is named next week, there aren't many other tall forward options for GC (Sam Day no, Dixon maybe?)... I'd bring Clarke in...

I've got a question... cash isn't an issue; Cameron Guthrie (who I've heard nothing about until someone mentioned him in a thread 10 minutes ago and I looked up his price) or Stephen Morris?

[Windigo]

Is he worth it over Dazza P.

Can get Clarke if I downgrade Dazza>Hall?

should we start Magner or McDonald?

Macca.

Sounds like Clarke could be a semi-keeper, at least for the first half of the season if he is getting constant games... I think its worth it, Pfeiffer has a few other new players competing with him for games (McCarthy, Wingard, Gray moving into mids?) whereas if Hall is named next week, there aren't many other tall forward options for GC (Sam Day no, Dixon maybe?)... I'd bring Clarke in...

I've got a question... cash isn't an issue; Cameron Guthrie (who I've heard nothing about until someone mentioned him in a thread 10 minutes ago and I looked up his price) or Stephen Morris?

Well I just checked.....Cannot get Marty through a trade of Morris. Only Ellis. Only way for me to get Clarke is to downgrade Dazza P to Couch......

Guthrie is ticking all the correct boxes down at the Cattery. He got talked up after a 10-15 possession game. With Milburn gone he could slot in nicely. Better JS than Morris. Dunno about scoring ability.