Ask Q: Panic Saturday (24/3/12)

[Master Q]

Ask Q is back! Ask me your questions, and I'll give you my opinion.

Please refrain from answering questions, if you want to start a discussion on a player make a thread  ;)
If you find my advice helpful, don't be afraid to give me a Cheer  ;)
Finally, I will let you guys know when I am locking the thread.

Thanks
-Q  ;)

Fire away  :)

EDIT: Thread closes at 5:45 PM EST!

[Bill Manspeaker]

i literally just turned Townsend into Marty Clarke (a couple of posts down from you)

was that the right choice?

[footyfan11]

thoughts on Ivan Maric? currently have him ruck #1, going with a mid pricer 3 rookie set up. dont want to hear the negatives of this strategy but rather thoughts on maric

[Master Q]

i literally just turned Townsend into Marty Clarke (a couple of posts down from you)

was that the right choice?

I think so.

thoughts on Ivan Maric? currently have him ruck #1, going with a mid pricer 3 rookie set up. dont want to hear the negatives of this strategy but rather thoughts on maric

Shocking player. Not worth it IMO.

[T Dog]

Hey Q, any thoughts on Rhys Stanley getting game time with the Saints early this year?

[footyfan11]

thoughts on Ivan Maric? currently have him ruck #1, going with a mid pricer 3 rookie set up. dont want to hear the negatives of this strategy but rather thoughts on maric

Shocking player. Not worth it IMO.
[/quote]

but as #1 ruck, surely underpriced at 52?

[Loose]

Currenlty got H Mac as my second ruck, should i bite the bullet and just start giles and use the money elsewhere?

Also is Shiel, Mcdonald and Kennedy too many GWS in the middle?

[Master Q]

Hey Q, any thoughts on Rhys Stanley getting game time with the Saints early this year?

Not too sure, but still wouldn't consider him.

thoughts on Ivan Maric? currently have him ruck #1, going with a mid pricer 3 rookie set up. dont want to hear the negatives of this strategy but rather thoughts on maric

Shocking player. Not worth it IMO.

but as #1 ruck, surely underpriced at 52?
[/quote]
I don't see any upside TBH...

Currenlty got H Mac as my second ruck, should i bite the bullet and just start giles and use the money elsewhere?

Also is Shiel, Mcdonald and Kennedy too many GWS in the middle?

1. Who is your 1st ruck?

2. No, IMO. As long as you'll be ok when it's R11,12,13.

[Loose]

McEvoy (just changed him from Berger)

Should be fine come the bye's as plan on trading them out plus got Swan, Ablett, Selwood and Murphy in the middle

[Jackina]

Dickson vs Sexton vs Hall

Will Couch play?

Should I start Bugg?

And final thoughts on Luke Parker!

Thanks!! :)

[Sleeken]

Hey Q,

Do you think Josh Hill is worth a gamble with Nicoski and Lecras out?

If not, can you suggest a different foward under 370k...hale, porps?

Cheers.

[Master Q]

McEvoy (just changed him from Berger)

Should be fine come the bye's as plan on trading them out plus got Swan, Ablett, Selwood and Murphy in the middle

I believe that the Mummy/Burger combo is great but if you can not afford it McEvoy is a good option as well. I'm not a massive fan of Hmac but I many people are going Prem/3 Rookies so I don't see too much wrong with it.

Dickson vs Sexton vs Hall

Will Couch play?

And final thoughts on Luke Parker!

Thanks!! :)

1. Errrrr? Why are you considering them... Not sure if he'll play but what about Kerridge? Can you afford a 104k player?

2. I don't think so. Magner will though.

3. No.

[Master Q]

Hey Q,

Do you think Josh Hill is worth a gamble with Nicoski and Lecras out?

If not, can you suggest a different foward under 370k...hale, porps?

Cheers.

Porps.

[Loose]

What about Dangerfield, could this really be his year? He's really tempting with the bye's etc

[kilbluff1985]

Is the Easter Bunny real?