Please help - urgent!!

[tommy10]

Guys, trying to get all your advice to see which combo I should go for so I can finalise team before lockout:

Selwood and Chappy OR Watson and Goodes

Thoughts???

[Goddard_18]

watson and goodes
chappy hammies are too much of a worry for me

[tommy10]

Thanks Goddard_18.

I'm going for 3 Prem 3 rook structure. Do u still think Watson as third prem and Goodes?

Anyone else?

[tommy10]

Anyone?

[Noz]

If Watson didn't do his hamstrings last year he would be in the 600k+ catergory rates as a premium.
Go Watson and Goodes

[The Bomber]

selwood > watson

chappy > goodes (in the 1/2 half of the season)

im going with goodes being a perfect upgrade target...chappy easy draw in the first 1/2 espec...

watson will be close to selwoods scoring, but selwood just enough for me to go with selwood and chappy

[upthemaidens]

selwood/chappy..
   even though chappy has had hamstring problems in the past, think its fair to say watson is just as likely to miss games due too injuries.. also goodes NAB scores didnt exactly set the world on fire..
  i gather the selwood/goodes option is not available due to price, but surely u cant be too far short of affording it?

[Grazz]

Tbh Chappy hasnt had any Hamstring issues for a couple of seasons, he's had corkys etc but theyve pretty much got on top of his hamstring issues. Watson would be more of a concern for me, last years still fresh in my mind.

[tommy10]

selwood/chappy..
   even though chappy has had hamstring problems in the past, think its fair to say watson is just as likely to miss games due too injuries.. also goodes NAB scores didnt exactly set the world on fire..
  i gather the selwood/goodes option is not available due to price, but surely u cant be too far short of affording it?

Yeah Selwood and Goodes cant afford...about $25k short.

I have Malceski as 5th back, should I keep him and keep Selwood and Chappy or,
downgrade Malceski for Lake and upgrade Chappy to Goodes and $47k remaining.

Thoughts now?

[tommy10]

Yeah Selwood and Goodes cant afford...about $25k short.

I have Malceski as 5th back, should I keep him and keep Selwood and Chappy or,
downgrade Malceski for Lake and upgrade Chappy to Goodes and $47k remaining.

Thoughts now?
[/quote]

and keep Selwood. Thoughts?

[upthemaidens]

i dont think its worth rearranging your team now with only hours to go, just to make it fit.  u picked malceski for a reason, so stick with it..  just take selwood/ chappy,  infact both options are fine..
i wont go watson cause i started with him last year ,, but hes a great player and will score well

[kilbluff1985]

i'm to paranoid about Geelong resting players so Watson and Goodes for me

[tommy10]

i dont think its worth rearranging your team now with only hours to go, just to make it fit.  u picked malceski for a reason, so stick with it..  just take selwood/ chappy,  infact both options are fine..
i wont go watson cause i started with him last year ,, but hes a great player and will score well

Yeah picked Malceski only b/c he is ex-prem. Plus he is named in mid. so tempted to keep him