Going for another great year this year, give me a rate out of 10???

[MattyB_10]

Hi guys, can you give me a rate or comment on my team. All comments greatly appreciated.

Backs: Goddard, Deledio, Suckling, Grimes, Birchall, Hargrave, Bugg; Ellis, Townsend
Mids: Ablett, Montagna, Martin, Hayes, Coniglio, Shiel; McDonald, Magner
Rucks; Sandilands, Giles; Redden, Stephenson
Fwds: Franklin, Goodes, Fyfe, Cloke, Reiwoldt, Porplyzia, D.Smith; A.Kennedy, Hall

Thanks in advance  :)

[crows23]

nb, montagna is interesting choice

[mpollock]

Which Roo?? Jack then yes ... Nick then no from my perspective.
Like the Montagna pick ... not sold on Hayes early ... think he will kill it after about 5 rounds ...
Would wait until Grimes is picked but may work ... or may be better going with Lake who is slightly less injury prone.

Overall assuming J not N Roo then 8.5/10 ...

[Colliwobblers]

Looks like 6 is the common thoughts a few reasons why

1. Grimes - huge risk
2. Cloke over all those mid/fwds ? he is great but all key fwds have up and down days. and can't see him bettering last years output, may even struggle to match it.
3. You have 4 premiums in your backline on a round 13 bye, will be VERY costly in round 13.
4. Sandilands - will be rested and maybe injured again? just a hunch.
5. Hayes is a risk - martin should be in your fwd line. No way he will score enough to justify a spot in your midfield

That's it otherwise good looking side make sure all your rooks play round 1 or switch them up

Good Luck for the season

[yorgis]

you tossing rnd 13? no defenders left and most of your mids are going awol