Rate my team, and ill rate yours

[RichoMan]

Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Malceski, Lake, ellis, bugg
Morris, townsend

Ablett, swan, boyd, selwood, shiel, magner
mcdonald, pfeiffer

Mummy, giles
redden, stephensen

Buddy, fyfe, martin, sidebottom, dangerfield, porps, smith
kennedy, hall

9k in the bank, going for league

Please give it a rate, I'm open for any suggestions, be as harsh as you want.
cheers, will rate back

[tor01doc]

Hello,

I don't like it as much as some of the others I've had the privilegde of rating.

Malceski D4 is risky, especially with Lake @ D5.

4 mid guns worries me, especially with McDonald there. I don't think he'll score very highly and worry about the vest for him since he so old.

F4 is weak too.

And you're not going set and forget.

Might work but I wouldn't do it.

[craig22]

do like danger and porps in the same side i think u could downgrade dnager and upgrade sidebottom and it would look better.

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,52717.0.html My Team!!

[RichoMan]

ok, i updated it...

Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, broughtan, malceski, ellis, bugg
Morris, smedts

Ablett, swan, selwood, coniglio, shiel, magner
Mcdonald, ledger

Mummy, giles
redden, stephensen

Buddy, goodes, fyfe, chappy, martin, porps, smith
Kennedy, Hall

Thoughts?

[RichoMan]

????

[bkp130]

B- Really good i wouldnt change anything
M- Good again but i personally wouldnt have mcdonald as i dont see him playing every game
R- Good again.
F- Would only change goodes due to i personally think he is on the decline

overall i give it a 9.5/10. Awesome team all over

please rate mine now

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,52912.0.html

i have gone for the 8 rookie midfield approach and stocke up on premiums everywhere else

[RichoMan]

who would you rather than goods then?

[tommy10]

What does every1 think about McDonald now haha