JOHN MCCARTHY OR LUKE PARKER??

[smashbox]

which one would you pick?

[dmac07]

McCarthy, will play a larger role for Port than Parker will for Sydney. Lots of game time on the wing for McCarthy this year.

[ando_10]

starting to like mccarthy will see alot of midfield time this year i think and he can kick goals.

[TheAnt]

I personally wouldn't go for mid priced midfielders with the midfield rookies available, if I had to choose though I would go Mccarthy, seems like he's thriving at a new club, but dont see him averaging more than in the 80-90 range.

[ando_10]

I personally wouldn't go for mid priced midfielders with the midfield rookies available, if I had to choose though I would go Mccarthy, seems like he's thriving at a new club, but dont see him averaging more than in the 80-90 range.

would hardly call 280k a mid pricer.

[TheMailman]

I personally wouldn't go for mid priced midfielders with the midfield rookies available, if I had to choose though I would go Mccarthy, seems like he's thriving at a new club, but dont see him averaging more than in the 80-90 range.

would hardly call 280k a mid pricer.

Well he isn't a premium, nor a rookie

Therefore, logic tells you he's a mid pricer

[TheAnt]

I consider below 200,000 rookie price. Anything above is mid price.

[Wes Mantooth]

I consider below 200,000 rookie price. Anything above is mid price.

agreed and anything over 500,000 is premium.

[ando_10]

I personally wouldn't go for mid priced midfielders with the midfield rookies available, if I had to choose though I would go Mccarthy, seems like he's thriving at a new club, but dont see him averaging more than in the 80-90 range.

would hardly call 280k a mid pricer.

Well he isn't a premium, nor a rookie

Therefore, logic tells you he's a mid pricer

true

thought you would have premiums- mid pricers- cheapies- rookies.

[newfreofan]

This is a decision I'm struggling with too. Would rather go with one of them who I know will get games and score than a kid who might get rotated and wear the vest.