P.Bower vs M.Clarke vs Tomlinson vs Guthrie

[Degsman]

Who is the better option in the backline??

[Hydra]

Not Bower.

[Jay]

Guthrie???

[Degsman]

will guthrie get games??

[Jay]

Yeah

[Babylove]

I would say Clarke.  Now I will put a rider on this and say that I am a Collingwood supporter, but Clarke has shown the most growth in form through the NAB Cup as he picked up the game again, as he ended up averaging 75 SC points a game (according to the Herald Sun) despite a shocker first up.  He will als potentially will spend some time in the midfield which will help his scores.

[Degsman]

If I get clarke I will have to get Heath Shaw instead of scotland in the backline.....

[Babylove]

If I get clarke I will have to get Heath Shaw instead of scotland in the backline.....

I don't think you'd be losing a lot to be honest, but again I am a Collingwood supporter, so I may be a little biased :P