First team selection...good or bad?

[Scrays]

Def: 1. Goddard, B 2. Deledio, B 3. Broughton, G 4. Lake, B 5. Guthrie, C 6. Ellis, B 7. Morris, S 23. Bugg, T 24. Darley, S

Mid: 8. Boyd, M 9. Selwood, J 10. Thompson, S 11. Cotchin, T 12. Caddy, J 13. Coniglio, S 25. Smith, C 26. Shiel, D

Rck: 14. Mumford, S 15. Giles, J 27. Redden, J 28. Stephenson, O

Fwd: 16. Franklin, L 17. Goodes, A 18. Fyfe, N 19. Pavlich, M 20. Dangerfield, P 21. Porplyzia, J 22. Smith, D 29. Pfeiffer, D
30. Kennedy, A

Be great to get some feedback. I'm thinking the DEF needs some work and also a re-shuffle of FWD/MID players.

Looking for league win...there has been a lot of trash talk and time to get serious  ;)

[essendon33]

i like it!.
Few different picks int here such as guthrie who i rate as a smokie this year..
not sure about broughton, think there may be risk when mundy and barlow come back with role changes etc.. the only reason i didnt get him.
9/10

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,52652.0.html

[Scrays]

I was also thinking of Hargrave instead of Lake

Whats the thoughts on McEvoy?

[essendon33]

McEvoy im not sure, i think hes gona get better.. but theres something i dont like about him..
me personally went cox mumford so i dont have to think about that :)

[Scrays]

Last minute look at the team...

Thinking of Carrazzo instead of broughton and then upgrade cotchin to Jobe Watson, Hodge or Mundy

What do you think?