Townsend or mohr?

Started by Footyrulz, March 23, 2012, 10:26:02 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Townsend or mohr?

Townsend
11 (47.8%)
Mohr
12 (52.2%)

Total Members Voted: 2

Footyrulz

Mohr has better JS but Townsend should score better as Mohr will be playing a limited key defensive role.

Who is a better pick?

supercoach addict

Townsend. Mohr will score like Presti

mdub

neither ther is way better scoring gws backs then these two

Mozza3

Townsend has been given tagging jobs so that's promising but Mohr should get lots of games as well.

port2012

im just dam confused, went from darley to townsend now to mohr.
:-\

Colliwobblers

Mohr but its not a concern for either has a key role in the side, i would say due to his ability to play key defence and that being a unique ability in a side Mohr has slightly better JS Townsend is the tagger but there could be other midifelders that come ot be able to play that role also. Sheeds seems dead set on giving the role to townsend at this stage however.

Take your pick they should both score shower.... a tagger and a key defender PASS

Colliwobblers

If you are stuck for def rooks join the club but have

1. ellis
2. bugg
3. Guthrie
4. Clark
5. Morris
6. Smedts
7. Darley- when and if plays
8. Tomlinson
9. Mohr
10. Townsend

PICCOLLO

Midfield tagger vs key position defender.  Mohr scored slightly better in nab but id pick a midfielder over a defender like mohr anyday.  Wont be much between them and wouldnt play either of them on the ground.

jeesh

Townsend's JS is questionable but who are the other taggers? I know Macdonald was used as a tagger throughout his career but at his age he surely couldn't run with someone all day.

port2012

chad cornes on radio in adelaide gave a huge rap to townsend,  said hes like a josh carr, chases and tackles,   i think he will do alot of tackling coz gws wont hardly touch the ball, tackles are easy points

PICCOLLO

Quote from: jeesh on March 23, 2012, 11:16:15 PM
Townsend's JS is questionable but who are the other taggers? I know Macdonald was used as a tagger throughout his career but at his age he surely couldn't run with someone all day.

Dont think his js is too bad.  He'll get a good run.  If mohr's form remains bad, he might be in and out himself.

thebrock

Quote from: mdub on March 23, 2012, 10:52:14 PM
neither ther is way better scoring gws backs then these two

With Darley not picked and I assume most have Bugg, who would you suggest? Hombsch? Have considered him but unsure of his JS.

jeesh

Quote from: PICCOLLO on March 23, 2012, 11:18:51 PM
Dont think his js is too bad.  He'll get a good run.  If mohr's form remains bad, he might be in and out himself.

Who will come in for Mohr? Sesgrave is the only other key defender I'm aware of.

port2012

Quote from: jeesh on March 23, 2012, 11:29:22 PM
Quote from: PICCOLLO on March 23, 2012, 11:18:51 PM
Dont think his js is too bad.  He'll get a good run.  If mohr's form remains bad, he might be in and out himself.

Who will come in for Mohr? Sesgrave is the only other key defender I'm aware of.

josh bruce could easily replace mohr, 

jeesh

I forgot about Frost as well