Ask the Dog!

[underdog11]

With one day left to partial lockout, im sure there are a lot of Q's that are being asked, ask the Dog and i'll give it my best crack.

[fidou]

Roof, Roof, Roof!!!

[T Dog]

leads me to think you must also have a lesser crack

With one day left to partial lockout, im sure there are a lot of Q's that are being asked, ask the Dog and i'll give it my best crack.

[owenbond007]

leads me to think you must also have a lesser crack

With one day left to partial lockout, im sure there are a lot of Q's that are being asked, ask the Dog and i'll give it my best crack.

+1 love it. Lets try and put off as many that have players the same.

[underdog11]

hahah  :)

[T Dog]

No offence there Underdog. Just wanted to do the crack joke

[underdog11]

No offence there Underdog. Just wanted to do the crack joke

None taken T-Dog i figured. You have a question though?

[Zombie2.5]

Lets all ask the poll king..

Why are there no questions!!

Anyways How many GWS rooks do you think is reasonable.
And Kennedy or Cameron for fwd line(or other GWS fwd besides D.smith)

Do you think i should Coniglio(great JS and is a gun) or try and get a cheap midpricer (e.g. lucas, caddy, mccarthy, parker)

[Scrads]

Here you go Mr Dog, please help  :)

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,52520.0.html

[underdog11]

Lets all ask the poll king..

Why are there no questions!!

Anyways How many GWS rooks do you think is reasonable.
And Kennedy or Cameron for fwd line(or other GWS fwd besides D.smith)

Do you think i should Coniglio(great JS and is a gun) or try and get a cheap midpricer (e.g. lucas, caddy, mccarthy, parker)

Finally haha. I think 6 is pushing it 7's the limit. I have Kennedy, Smith, Shiel, McDonald, Bugg, Giles.

Kennedy! Cameron has great js, but will get regular 40s and 50s kennedy will be 60s-80s.

Conilgio is a gun but i would personally want to store the money or use it elsewere when there are options like Shiel, McDonald, Smith, Magner etc. If you really dont need the cash tehn take coniglio, but otherwise look elsewere.

[T Dog]

A question to stump the underdog?
Why would I choose any GWS 17 or 18 yo rook other than Giles ( whatever his age is) in the hope that they will get any consistant  game time or allowed to get a game based on the rd 1competition they face?  Sydney is not the worst they will meet, but head to head these GWS boys will be clobbered IMO.
Just thought I'd ask as you seem to be having a quiet kick back tonight.

[underdog11]

A question to stump the underdog?
Why would I choose any GWS 17 or 18 yo rook other than Giles ( whatever his age is) in the hope that they will get any consistant  game time or allowed to get a game based on the rd 1competition they face?  Sydney is not the worst they will meet, but head to head these GWS boys will be clobbered IMO.
Just thought I'd ask as you seem to be having a quiet kick back tonight.

Because blokes like Shiel and Trealoar are guns! Clifton and Miles are second to them in Sheedy's old has been eyes

[T Dog]

 :o Its just that they will be clobbered each week. No ongoing potential really? Bench fodder at best. Then again I may be just stirring you up ::)

[Jalapeno]

Should i play 4 guns and 2 mid pricers in def or the forwards? And why.... I can either chuck hargrave in my defence or porps up front :)

[underdog11]

Should i play 4 guns and 2 mid pricers in def or the forwards? And why.... I can either chuck hargrave in my defence or porps up front :)

defence definetly better options :)