Guthrie or Marty Clarke?!

[lenny99]

Gday boys,

My defence at the moment is:

Scotland, Goddard, Deledio, Birchall, Hargrave, Guthrie, Bugg (Townsend, Ellis)

Im tossing up between Guthrie or Clarke

Who has the better job security? Clarke's pre-season scores havent been too enticing and Guthrie's have been alright

Who do you reckon I should go ?

[essendon2]

you've got 4 premo's missing round 13!

but Guthrie > Clarke

[Ricochet]

i like Guthrie over Clarke

[browny_wce]

would say Clarke is a shoe in

will take him a while to get back used to competitive AFL but he will be locked down in that backline for the Pies
the only bad thing against him is that Malthouse loved him (thats why he got him back) but just not sure how Bucks feels about him

[MiGZ]

would say Clarke is a shoe in

will take him a while to get back used to competitive AFL but he will be locked down in that backline for the Pies
the only bad thing against him is that Malthouse loved him (thats why he got him back) but just not sure how Bucks feels about him

Actually it was Buckley who got him back, and i've seen a  couple of articles in the past few months where Bucks has said how good of a pre season Marty is having. He'll play games early, then its up to him to keep his spot. Probably be a battle between him and Goldsack all year.

[Crows84]

have had clarke in my side through most of my team change ups but after the nab im liking guthrie, also like him as alot of ppl going with clarke so thinking if he can hold a spot he should do ok, guthrie a possible green vester more so than clarke?

[The_Captain]

guthrie for points, but like clarke better for JS. But thats only my opinion :)

[Mr.Craig]

Duigan, Lower, Heppell, Stanley....Would kill to have just one rookie/cheapie of that quality to pick this year.

Oh well. I've gone for a mid pricer in my P6 so I don't have as much to worry about...until that guy fails horribly.