Who makes way in GWS team when Power & Scully are ready ??

Started by camtinley, March 23, 2012, 07:06:21 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

camtinley

Eveyone is top heavy with GWS players but who is the most vulnerable in the named R1 side when Power, Scully and also for that matter O'hAilpin & Brogan are ready to play ??

dmac07

Impossible to say really, whoever has poor games in Rd 1-2 before those guys come back in.

TheMailman

Quote from: dmac07 on March 23, 2012, 07:11:38 PM
Impossible to say really, whoever has poor games in Rd 1-2 before those guys come back in.

exactly what I was going to say.

Seing as both Scully and Power and midfield type players there's a possible 10-15 players that could be dropped

meow meow

Greene and Tyson will make way for Scully and Power.
Setanta will play as a swing man so probably Tomlinson.
Hampton, Townsend and Wilson aren't safe. They've been on the list for a year though and know the gameplan.

There will be injuries and suspensions and that will probably decide who gets replaced.

camtinley

So which players will be given some latitude even if they do play bad -> average. I'm thinking Bugg, Shiels, D.Smith, Coniglio, so N.Wilson is not worth picking I'm guessing.

dmac07

Clifton also likely to come in quickly. There going to be heavy rotations, id say only maybr 5-6 rookeis will play the first 10 games without missing.

Talisman

Quote from: meow meow on March 23, 2012, 07:29:46 PM
Greene and Tyson will make way for Scully and Power.
Setanta will play as a swing man so probably Tomlinson.
Hampton, Townsend and Wilson aren't safe. They've been on the list for a year though and know the gameplan.

There will be injuries and suspensions and that will probably decide who gets replaced.


Gee I reckon that's tough on Tomlinson. Don't get me wrong, I completely agree with you that it will happen, but I don't think that it should happen.

Maybe I'm being a little bit unfair, but if you take all the money/fame/advertising the game away, who is the better player: Tomlinson or Folau? Imo, a fwd line of Tomlinson & Cameron, with Setanta as the 3rd tall/2nd ruck would work fairly well... But then again I guess I should cut Folau some slack, he did shows some signs against the Hawks...

4INAROW

na your right folaus shizen houzen, but they wont drop their poster boy unless he really puts in a couple of showzen games in a row

port2012

i like the looks of josh bruce, but didnt get named, was guna be my smokie   :'(

4INAROW

he did look good, i think he's a lil younger and underdeveloped so he's got that against him

T Dog

Any of the 17 or 18 yo who need resting. This team will be shuffled to fit like no other...surely. Watch the game tomorrow. Sydney has 1 rookie Cunningham. GWS has just a few more. This is not the Suns model from last year.