Goodwin v S Johnson

Started by valkorum, March 04, 2009, 05:33:25 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

valkorum

I am undecided here

What are peoples thoughts on these 2.  Is the rumour true that Goodwin is gonna float a bit more down the half backs?

Yakuza

Personally, I'd be going with Johnson. Can really turn it on.
Plus he's from Geelong where the DT points are usually high, whereas the crows aren't as much.
Had Johnson the last two years and have been very happy with him!

valkorum

I have also had Johnson previously and been very happy but a Goodwin playing in the half backs picking up cheap positions interests me from a DT point of view. 

shog

Yeah Goodwin will be skulking around half back picking up easy kicks! perfect! but the fact Johnson is from Geelong is of couse v.tempting.

valkorum

Now can you see why I am having a hard choice between the two.  I think Johnson will have higher scores but possibly Goodwin being more consistent, especially if skulking around half back.