IS 3 GWS MIDS TOO MANY?????

Started by Jimbo_11, March 22, 2012, 07:45:26 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

3 too many???

yes
10 (29.4%)
no
24 (70.6%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Jimbo_11

considering starting with congilio, mcdonald and shiel
is this too many or is it worht the risk??

Ricochet

i have 3 starting and 1 on the bench

Justin Bieber

Starting 3 is too many, having 3 in mids though isn't that bad...

Memphistopheles

I'm strongly considering having Smith, McDonald and Shiel in my mids with Magner the other.

Smith for dpp link and Shiel and McDonald as cash cows.

I don't think it matters as they will upgraded before the byes.

Rommas

I'll have Coniglio and Sheil starting with McDonald on the bench, but I got Pendles, Boyd, Ablett and Redden so I should be ok

Jimbo_11

yeh i reckon congilio and shiel on the field with mcdonald as emg is the way to go now, as there isnt too many other rookie options..

Windigo


Jimbo_11

Quote from: Windigo on March 22, 2012, 07:59:13 PM
No love for Toby Greene?
doesnt have as good js as the others, and being named on the bench makes me think hes a good candidate for the vest

Windigo

True that.

But such a gun at lower levels.

Holz

i cant find a 3rd viable option after shiel,mcdonal and magner im thinking of bringing lids into the middle and just going bugg instead.

Windigo

Why not put Devon in mids?  ???

Don't put Lids in the guts.

Jukes

As long as you don't have too many of them starting it's fine.

Bones Bombers

I will have Shiel on he bench this week and 2 GWS players on the field.
Haven't seen wether Shiel can play well at AFL pace yet, have given him a spot on my team purely on potential.

Windigo

Quote from: Jukes on March 22, 2012, 08:15:10 PM
As long as you don't have too many of them starting it's fine.

I have 3, maybe 4.

Giles, Devon, Kennedy & undecided whether to get Tomlinson.

MLS

I have 2, both on the bench.

Old Mcdonald (emergency) & Shiel.

Don't forget, this could be fools gold, and an absolute smashing on Saturday night.