just give it a thought...

Started by Jay, March 22, 2012, 06:41:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

which one vvv

cox/porplyzia
7 (77.8%)
mumford/lynch (crows)
2 (22.2%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Jay

Which combo? Cox & Porps or Mummy & Lynch (crows)

Ok at first look i bet you'll all say cox/porps...but let me explain! Cox cant get better, and with nic nat gradually getting more ruck time and cox has been played up forward which will limit his scoring! Mummy on the other hand can improve and I believe will average 115+...porps is the common F6/7 option but he will be playing key foward, resulting in inconsistent scores and his shoulders are a worry too. Lynch will play a sort of high-half forward role and has no injury troubles and he has a higher points per time on ground during nab!

So who should it be? :)

Capper

i dont understand all the hype around Lynch. I agree that the tag will go to porps over Lynch but always be wary of people leaving other clubs because they cant get a start

quinny88

Quote from: Jayman on March 22, 2012, 06:41:46 PM
Which combo? Cox & Porps or Mummy & Lynch (crows)

Ok at first look i bet you'll all say cox/porps...but let me explain! Cox cant get better, and with nic nat gradually getting more ruck time and cox has been played up forward which will limit his scoring! Mummy on the other hand can improve and I believe will average 115+...porps is the common F6/7 option but he will be playing key foward, resulting in inconsistent scores and his shoulders are a worry too. Lynch will play a sort of high-half forward role and has no injury troubles and he has a higher points per time on ground during nab!

So who should it be? :)

arent you answering your own question? sounds like youve talked yourself into mummy/lynch already lol

Jay

haha yeah it does seem like that...i was just giving my reason behind considering it because most people at first glance would just say cox/porps withouth seeing the facts

CrowsFan

Porps wont be playing key forward. Have you forgotten Adelaide have Tippett and Walker for those positions, plus Jacobs when he goes down forward for a rest and either Tippett or McKernan go in to the ruck!

ubeaut

Finally someone has the same doubts on Cox as me! As for Porps he's a risk but as CF said won't be a KPP. So Porps for me but still can't decide between Cox and Mummy.