The "Who to Start" thread

[PowerBug]

The title says it all, a thread where you simply ask, who starts. Please do not ask questions on who to get, just on who gets the nod over others. This will mainly occur with the rookies, but anyway.


I'll kick things off: Which two of Ellis, Morris and Bugg start??

[Ricochet]

I'm in the same boat with these three. I'm thinking  Bugg doesn't have much chance of the vest, and Ellis proly doesn't either. So i would go those two.

I have one.
Need to pick two of Hall, D.Smith, Kennedy and Dickson?

[Mick Neill]

Devon Smith...   8)

[egosbar]

smith weedon saad kerridge two too start in forwards

at the moment smith and weedon

[Cicjose]

Murphy or Selwood?

[danger]

Murphy or Selwood?

Both likely for the vest.. wasting you time with juniors like that..l

[Bones Bombers]

I'm in the same boat with these three. I'm thinking  Bugg doesn't have much chance of the vest, and Ellis proly doesn't either. So i would go those two.

I have one.
Need to pick two of Hall, D.Smith, Kennedy and Dickson?

Agree with you on Bugg and Ellis. If Smith and Kennedy are named this week then you have to start them cos we won't know the others till next week.

[Justin Bieber]

What rookies to start? From GWS.

[Ricochet]

I'm in the same boat with these three. I'm thinking  Bugg doesn't have much chance of the vest, and Ellis proly doesn't either. So i would go those two.

I have one.
Need to pick two of Hall, D.Smith, Kennedy and Dickson?

Agree with you on Bugg and Ellis. If Smith and Kennedy are named this week then you have to start them cos we won't know the others till next week.

Cheers, we'll nearly have to start all our GWS rooks (if they're named) over other rooks in case the Non GWS rooks aren't named for their club.... farrk

[Bones Bombers]

I'm in the same boat with these three. I'm thinking  Bugg doesn't have much chance of the vest, and Ellis proly doesn't either. So i would go those two.

I have one.
Need to pick two of Hall, D.Smith, Kennedy and Dickson?

Agree with you on Bugg and Ellis. If Smith and Kennedy are named this week then you have to start them cos we won't know the others till next week.

Cheers, we'll nearly have to start all our GWS rooks (if they're named) over other rooks in case the Non GWS rooks aren't named for their club.... farrk

You got it mate hope the others do get a game but have to put gws boys on the field

[ArthurDent]

smith weedon saad kerridge two too start in forwards

at the moment smith and weedon

smith and kerridge for me from those.


my query is midfield 3 of, shiel mcdonald, c.smith and kerridge who misses out?

[Sabretooth Tigers]

Kerridge misses out, Sheed's has a soft spot for Curtly.

Lake   Hargrave   M Golby
which one misses out ???

[Kuruki]

What rookies to start? From GWS.

For me i will start whoever is named to play. I would hate to decide i want to start Ellis over Bugg then come next weekend Ellis is not playing. For this week only i'm handing out debuts for all my GWS soldiers.

[Justin Bieber]

What rookies to start? From GWS.

For me i will start whoever is named to play. I would hate to decide i want to start Ellis over Bugg then come next weekend Ellis is not playing. For this week only i'm handing out debuts for all my GWS soldiers.

Also I meant who will be sub??? That's my biggest concern.

[Capper]

What rookies to start? From GWS.

For me i will start whoever is named to play. I would hate to decide i want to start Ellis over Bugg then come next weekend Ellis is not playing. For this week only i'm handing out debuts for all my GWS soldiers.

Also I meant who will be sub??? That's my biggest concern.

Miles i think will have the vest if named. I wont be starting any GWS players in my team. I only have Bugg, Giles and Devon Sandwiches in my team