The "Who to Start" thread

[Justin Bieber]

What rookies to start? From GWS.

For me i will start whoever is named to play. I would hate to decide i want to start Ellis over Bugg then come next weekend Ellis is not playing. For this week only i'm handing out debuts for all my GWS soldiers.

Also I meant who will be sub??? That's my biggest concern.

Miles i think will have the vest if named. I wont be starting any GWS players in my team. I only have Bugg, Giles and Devon Sandwiches in my team

You do have a heap of mid pricers aye? I have 7 GWS rooks...

[Capper]

What rookies to start? From GWS.

For me i will start whoever is named to play. I would hate to decide i want to start Ellis over Bugg then come next weekend Ellis is not playing. For this week only i'm handing out debuts for all my GWS soldiers.

Also I meant who will be sub??? That's my biggest concern.

Miles i think will have the vest if named. I wont be starting any GWS players in my team. I only have Bugg, Giles and Devon Sandwiches in my team

You do have a heap of mid pricers aye? I have 7 GWS rooks...

between the prices of 300K-150K i have 7 guys but will probably get rid of porps. These guys can score but just like the GC players last year i dont trust the rookies. Giles killed it at port 2nds last year, Devon sandwiches as a DPP and Bugg on the bench in Def

[Capper]

im must have changed my team last night as bugg out, miles in

[Justin Bieber]

im must have changed my team last night as bugg out, miles in

Miles out, Bugg in?

[Cicjose]

so murphy or selwood to start?

[GlassHarmonium]

j.giles or j.redden for 2nd ruck spot????

[Zombie2.5]

I'm in the same boat with these three. I'm thinking  Bugg doesn't have much chance of the vest, and Ellis proly doesn't either. So i would go those two.

I have one.
Need to pick two of Hall, D.Smith, Kennedy and Dickson?

Agree with you on Bugg and Ellis. If Smith and Kennedy are named this week then you have to start them cos we won't know the others till next week.

Yeah bugg and ellis, but morris did get 90 in NAB4 so you could go him but imo the other two.

smith weedon saad kerridge two too start in forwards

at the moment smith and weedon

smith and kerridge for me from those.


my query is midfield 3 of, shiel mcdonald, c.smith and kerridge who misses out?

let kerridge miss out

Kerridge misses out, Sheed's has a soft spot for Curtly.

Lake   Hargrave   M Golby
which one misses out ???

:o
is this a joke? or do you have no rookies and benching 200k guys.
but lake misses out for me.

im must have changed my team last night as bugg out, miles in

Miles out, Bugg in?

how can you trade bugg out for miles or vice versa which ever, miles is mid and bugg is defender, bugg playing, miles not.

j.giles or j.redden for 2nd ruck spot????

Giles over redden, giles has shown more potential and mature aged, redden is a rookie that had a few good games(he could keep it up though) giles over redden at this stage

[Doyle]

Seeing as Miles is not playing and Cliffton is the sub. I'm probably going with Coniglio, but that could change ::)

[lollipop man]

Here's a toughy (imo anyway), Shiel, McDonald, Magner and C. Smith. Can only start 2. Shiel and Macdo both starting on the ball, but Magner is a beast. IMO it's out of these three, but who?

[4INAROW]

shiel and jmac dude, magner may not play rd1 and smith may not play for 5 weeks, who knows.

upto you.

[lollipop man]

shiel and jmac dude, magner may not play rd1 and smith may not play for 5 weeks, who knows.

upto you.

Can easily start Magner and then have another player emergency.

[Doyle]

Who to start? M. Clarke or Ellis?

[Ricochet]

Who to start? M. Clarke or Ellis?

Ellis

[Ajax22]

Who to start? M. Clarke or Ellis?

Ellis by a long way

[elephants]

Ellis or Morris (if we assume neither starts as sub)

Dickson or Hall or Couch

Cheers!