Mummy or McEvoy?

[13Brummy]

I think McEvoy will play more games as Mumford is more prone to injury or suspension, but Mumford has a higher ceiling.  They are priced similar but I'm currently on McEvoy but he's far from locked.  Help!

[Jukes]

They will both average ~100 I reckon Mummy will average higher tho.

[PowerBug]

Who is your other rucks?? I have both amazingly. Mummy if i had to pick one.

[owenbond007]

mummy sydney have a good draw. Plus think his a better ruck.

[Disco]

If mummy has a good run with injury/suspesions then he will far outscore McEvoy

[Bak2Form]

poll says it all 92% mummy

[Boomz]

Mummy but McEvoy the safer option considering Mummy's injury/suspension record.

[Justin Bieber]

Mummy is killing the poll :o

[Flame]

Mummy out of these 2!! I'm also considering Jacobs!!

[Artax]

Mummy/Jacobs. Delicious combo

[hardnut]

If in doubt from a DT perspective always pick the better player in "real footy". That is clearly Mumford who could be a Swans B&F. I like many above have had Mummy-Jacobs locked all pre-season and no plan to change now