marty and cameron and christian

[woofy]

With Billie Smedts not impressing me that much in the pre-season and the risk of the dreaded vest im thinking of bringing in somebody more reliable in Marty Clarke or Cameron Guthrie into the side. I'm leaning towards Guthrie. Thoughts?

Also is Christian Howard in the dogs best 22? I've been impressed by how he went in the nab and scoring well doesn't hurt his chances. Just not sure about his JS. Thoughts?

thanks peeps!

[Mozza3]

I'd take Clarke over Guthrie just, think he might have the potential to score more. I think Howard is best 22, he's shown enough to warrant a spot I reckon.

[meow meow]

McCartney will go with Addison instead of Howard. Howard might get the vest if he makes the team.

[Manbearpig]

Collingwood's injuries should see Clarke get a decent run for a while. Geelong also has its injuries, but still, IDK whether Guthrie will avoid a vest if he plays. I think he's a gun in the making, so I'm tempted.

[ubeaut]

Collingwood's injuries should see Clarke get a decent run for a while. Geelong also has its injuries, but still, IDK whether Guthrie will avoid a vest if he plays. I think he's a gun in the making, so I'm tempted.

Dunno about that. Maxwell may be ready round 1,def round2. Johnson ready round 1 also. Tarrant is in doubt but his spot will go to a KPP rather than Clarke. Then there's Reid,Shaw,Toovey,Goldsack and O'Brien. I really want him to play regularly but with the Pies depth he will have to play out of his skin. He's fit as but he'll be still readjusting to the oval ball.
With Guthrie he's up against T.Hunt Hogan and Smedts, but I reckon he's ahead of those(but of course I'm not the coach) may get vested alot.

[sid3bysid3]

think marty will definitely play... he is fit as a fiddle so don't think they will green vest him at all.

will be serviceable and ave round 75 - others will lose value and reach BE earlier if green vested